border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Lizard Forums > Varanid

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-12-12, 06:39 AM   #211
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by infernalis View Post
Douglas Mader DVM, Veterinarian...



Allow me to translate this into easier to understand terms.

The fatty liver disease is brought on by the improper care of the animal, NOT the stored fat.

Read the quote carefully.

I can see where people would jump to the conclusion that mice cause the fatty liver disease, probably because they stopped reading at the word mice.

The fatty liver does not come into play until AFTER the improperly supported animal has already became sick of other reasons, like the renal failure associated with exposure and low level dehydration.

I highlighted (made boldface) where it clearly states that proper support of the animal is paramount in maintaining a healthy animal.

Michael Balsai on the Savannah Monitor Diet

*****************************
That is exactly right Wayne.
To go into it a little deeper. Reptles have a fatty because of their life stlye. Basically, whenever a reptile goes off feed for whatever reason, the stored fat is mobilized into the bloodstream and into the liver to be metabolized. This happens when they brumate or aestivate, just not in huge levels because of the slowed metabolism during this period. Once the animal resumes normal feeding, their systems do not rely on stored fats so the fat stops mobilizing into the bloodstream. The only time this is a problem but till never the cause of death or sickness is when the metabolism is running normally and the animal stops feeding. The stored fat is mobilized into the bloodstream in large enough amounts to where the animals metabolism does not keep up with the sudden influx of fats being moved to the liver. This causes the animal to have more fats in the liver. Fatty liver disease is associated with the reptile NOT feeding due to sickness and anorexia and NOT its actual diet. Fatty liver disease is a secondary issues to a primary problem. It is easy for a vet to say an animal has died from a fatty liver (that is usually where the necropsy ends) instead of looking into the reason that caused the animal to go off feed in the first place.

People seem to throw the term "fatty liver disease" around too freely without even understanding what causes it. It is quite fustrating especially when people want to use it in a debate about diet and how rodent prey is bad. It has nothing to do with diet or rodents. A reptile will have a fatty liver even on an all insect diet.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 07:15 AM   #212
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Ok so Im as tired of this debate as the next guy, but lets compile what actual proof we have, because that word gets thrown around a lot.

In the wild, studies (Cisse 1972, Losos and Greene 1988, Bennett multiple) have shown that these animals eat almost exclusively invertebrate prey, occasionally small vertebrates like frogs, and very, very occasionally rodents.

In captivity, after having this debate for months, I have found exactly 5 people who have raised this particular species with individuals older than 10 (4 with a mixed diet, 1 with an all invert diet). I know of no keeper in captivity to have raised them to older than 15. I am aware of 1 keeper who has bred them for more than a single generation. I know of no keeper who has tried to raise them both on a strict invert diet and a diet of inverts and rodents so as to compare the two. Every keeper has raised them either one way or the other. What this proves is two things. First, that we cannot seem to raise these animals successfully on either diet. Second, that there is proof for neither diet.

To scientifically disprove one or the other would require a keeper who had raised animals in similar situations on multiple diets (to show the variables) and then shown that one was lacking. There is evidence that both diets could be problematic, however there is not enough to disprove either. Where this leaves us is that it seems to be a personal choice on which one to feed. Im sure we all know by now where we each stand on this choice so everything else is a little academic at this point.

The most useful thing I have gleaned from this debate is that we have to pay more attention to what we are giving our feeders. Typical farm mice are high in fat. Typical farm insects are low in minerals. Mice become healthier if raised on a natural diet (not dogfood) and insects/inverts become vastly better reared on a nutritious diet. Those things are proved, and therefore proven to be better for Savannah monitors.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 07:34 AM   #213
mo9e64
Member
 
Join Date: Nov-2010
Posts: 290
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Is this not true,you set up your monitors in a set of conditions,and you feed them accordingly.If you change your conditions,you change your feeding-more or less depending which way direction you go.You are basing your opinion on your set of conditions-is it possible that changing your conditions could change what they need to fulfill their requirements.
In these circular arguments,the next talking point will be laziness.Because this leads to feeding more rodents which invertly reduces choices.'I work hard to give my animal variety in diet,putting in more rodents into the diet would be out of convenience' when infact it's getting the same results with less effort.It still doesn't prevent people from giving them a variety of foods.
mo9e64 is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 08:22 AM   #214
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I have found exactly 5 people who have raised this particular species with individuals older than 10 (4 with a mixed diet, 1 with an all invert diet).
Well now you have found 6.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I know of no keeper in captivity to have raised them to older than 15.
Well now you know of atleast one. I had a male live to almost 17 years old.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I know of no keeper who has tried to raise them both on a strict invert diet and a diet of inverts and rodents so as to compare the two.
My longest lived savannah was rasied on a primary rodent diet for the majority of its life.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Every keeper has raised them either one way or the other. What this proves is two things. First, that we cannot seem to raise these animals successfully on either diet. Second, that there is proof for neither diet..
I would call raising a monitor past 16 years pretty damn successful. My friend John raised his water to 18 years of age. The funny thing about that is that back then when we started raising these animals, deep substrates were never part of their husbandry requirement. Believe it or not, my sav was kept on corncob bedding foe at least 4 years of its captive life. Its substrate was news paper for a short period of time when I first got him. LOL.

So even with sub par conditions for the first few years of captive life and a mostly rodent diet, I still managed to keep mine alive for almost 17 years.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
To scientifically disprove one or the other would require a keeper who had raised animals in similar situations on multiple diets (to show the variables) and then shown that one was lacking.
And that was my point as well. I see lots of scare mongering and opinions being thrown around without any proof or study or literature. Equating mice to fast food burgers is wrong. Saying that rodent diets cause fatty liver disease is wrong. To say that an oportunistic feeder will get all it needs from an all insect diet is wrong.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
There is evidence that both diets could be problematic, however there is not enough to disprove either. Where this leaves us is that it seems to be a personal choice on which one to feed. Im sure we all know by now where we each stand on this choice so everything else is a little academic at this point.
Any diet will be problematic if the monitor is not being cared for properly. It is not the diet itself. It is the husbandry. Proper husbandry should not be a personal choice. It should be manditory when taking monitors on as captives. Again, it is not about the diet, it is about properly housing your monitor. There is room for academic in this debate. I am not sure why people shy away from academics or cast it in a negative light.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 09:14 AM   #215
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Ok thats great to know! Really, I am pretty excited about finding another keeper with that kind of experience. (However, the water monitor isnt applicable to a Savannah monitor diet debate as they are a totally different monitor with a very different diet.)

That is, perhaps sadly, the oldest Savannah I have heard of in captivity. Do you know what it died of? Again, Im not suggesting anything about diet, but that is still significantly lower than the expected life expectancy of these animals so Im wondering if you were able to figure out the cause of death.

The last part of what you said is where you get off track again. Again, there is no proof that an all invert diet does not meet their nutritional requirements.

And sorry if there was a misunderstanding, I was not saying that I shy away from academics at all. I consider myself to be one (Im a paleoanthropologist by training!) What I was saying is that us going on to state our respective points again and again is academic. Its a turn of phrase that basically means its a finicky debate.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-12-12, 09:52 AM   #216
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Ok thats great to know! Really, I am pretty excited about finding another keeper with that kind of experience. (However, the water monitor isnt applicable to a Savannah monitor diet debate as they are a totally different monitor with a very different diet.)
I agree, however, the age of that water is greater than any other captive I have heard of.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
That is, perhaps sadly, the oldest Savannah I have heard of in captivity. Do you know what it died of? Again, Im not suggesting anything about diet, but that is still significantly lower than the expected life expectancy of these animals so Im wondering if you were able to figure out the cause of death.
If that is the longest lived savannah you know of, how can we possibly estimate expected longevity? Do we really know how long they can live for in the wild or in captivity? We are all just guessing. What proof do we have that savannahs inparticular, can live up to 30 years? Maybe their true life expectancy is only half that.

And no, I never had a necropsy done on the animal. If I did, I know it would be inconclusive or inaccurate at best.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
The last part of what you said is where you get off track again. Again, there is no proof that an all invert diet does not meet their nutritional requirements.
I would say that the lack of proof that an all insect diet IN CAPTIVITY meets their needs is enough for me to keep feeding rodents to varanids. Especially from what I have experienced.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."

Last edited by infernalis; 03-12-12 at 10:58 AM..
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 10:00 AM   #217
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

I have heard of a number of other monitors living for much greater ages, just not Savannahs. As to how long they can live, you are right, it is totally a guess at this point. However, given that there are many other species that have lived to much greater ages, it seems likely that their life expectancy should also be greater than that. Again, thats just conjecture based on the known older ages of other species.

Also, given that there have been individuals who have raised them on a strict invertebrate diet is proof that they can be. Im not saying you shouldnt do whatever you chose, just that there isnt really proof one way or the other at this point.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 10:14 AM   #218
StuDude
Member
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 41
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bradyloach View Post
Oh okay, when I put water in his dish, should it be warm water? Or what
LUKEWARM is good
StuDude is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 10:53 AM   #219
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Also, given that there have been individuals who have raised them on a strict invertebrate diet is proof that they can be.
Can this be substantiated in any way? Not doubting your word. I have just never heard of anyone raising savannahs on an all insect diet to adulthood. Dwarf species, yes. But never savs.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 11:02 AM   #220
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Even though at one point I was convinced that chomper needed invertibrates, he did eat mice in the beginning, he ate vennison strips (raw) and turkey giblets.

So I cannot honestly profess he spent his entire life eating inverts.

also as ashamed of it as I am, he had eaten dog food, sometimes because I was a dillweed and gave it to him, and sometimes when free roaming the house he stole it from the dogs.

All I can say at this point, none of the mistakes will be repeated.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-12-12, 11:40 AM   #221
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Its not my word so much as the word of the people who have kept them. I belong to one forum where there are numerous members from Europe who have kept a few different species on inverts only (not just dwarfs), though none of those was exanthematicus. The one Savannah owner I know of who feeds exclusively inverts is very credible, though admittedly I have never seen it myself. Having said that Ive never seen yours either Gregg
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 12:17 PM   #222
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Its not my word so much as the word of the people who have kept them. I belong to one forum where there are numerous members from Europe who have kept a few different species on inverts only (not just dwarfs), though none of those was exanthematicus.
I agree that many species will do fine on a captive insect diet. I just can not see how it would be able to support a fully grown savannah. Our dwarfs are fed ALMOST and exclusive insect diet. But the are still offered rodents from time to time. Even the smallest species we have which are the kings monitors get rodents once in a while. The female more so now because she is gravid and about a week away from laying. The same for our 2 gravid gilleni females.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Having said that Ive never seen yours either Gregg
Unfortunately I have no photos of Ren (Named after Ren from Ren and Stimpy). I must have gone through 3 computers since he died and his last 3 years were spent with my sister. However, you have seen photos of the 5 year old male we have and the T+ albino wild caught female. Both are in perfect shape. Not fat at all. They are VERY active.

Their diet does include rodents. Not daily but I would say 2 to 3 days a week they get a rodent. The other days are spent chasing crickets, roaches, and digging up super worms. It is pretty crazy to see a 2 and a half foot savannah chasing and catching little crickets without missing.

I agree that insects should make up the bulk of their diet. However I do not agree with cutting rodents out of their diet and they should be offered more than just for an "occational treat".
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."

Last edited by Gregg M; 03-12-12 at 12:25 PM..
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 03:23 PM   #223
BarelyBreathing
Varanus Queen
 
BarelyBreathing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2012
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 5,078
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

I just want to say, I am very aware of fatty liver disease and it's causes. The POINT of that statement was that this would NOT occur without the excess fat that a diet rich in rodents offers.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Whimsical Observer
A seed is a tiny plant, in a box, with its lunch.
BarelyBreathing is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 03:54 PM   #224
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by BarelyBreathing View Post
I just want to say, I am very aware of fatty liver disease and it's causes. The POINT of that statement was that this would NOT occur without the excess fat that a diet rich in rodents offers.
You are obviously NOT aware of what causes it or what actually happens. Even if the diet consists of only insects, fatty liverdisease will still occure. Most cases of "fatty liver disease" are found in wild caught savannahs and not in captives that are overweight.

So if what you say is true, explain how wild caught savannahs can have "fatty liver disease" if all they are eating in the wild are inverts.

When a reptile stops feeding the stored fats will still rush into the liver regardless of its diet. So your point in your statement has nothing at all to do with the subject we are talking about. It is an entirely different topic.

You thought that fatty liver was caused by diet and you were wrong in your thinking. Again, it is your opinion that rodents are junk with nothing to back up your claim. It is fine that you have your opinion, but please, do not present something as fact unless you have facts to back it up. You type with such certainty yet what you type has no merit in this instance.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-12-12, 04:05 PM   #225
Bradyloach
Uncle Brady
 
Bradyloach's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb-2012
Location: Sudbury
Posts: 1,157
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

gregg, i dont have a full grown sav, as shes only 9 inches snout to vent. but how would one fill there 4 foot sav up with just inects? i dont feed rodents to my sav, i was just wondering on is it possible to fill up a full grown sav off just insects. that would be like 2000 crickets
__________________
The expert in anything was once a beginner
Bradyloach is offline  
Login to remove ads
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:06 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right