|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Ok so Im as tired of this debate as the next guy, but lets compile what actual proof we have, because that word gets thrown around a lot.
In the wild, studies (Cisse 1972, Losos and Greene 1988, Bennett multiple) have shown that these animals eat almost exclusively invertebrate prey, occasionally small vertebrates like frogs, and very, very occasionally rodents.
In captivity, after having this debate for months, I have found exactly 5 people who have raised this particular species with individuals older than 10 (4 with a mixed diet, 1 with an all invert diet). I know of no keeper in captivity to have raised them to older than 15. I am aware of 1 keeper who has bred them for more than a single generation. I know of no keeper who has tried to raise them both on a strict invert diet and a diet of inverts and rodents so as to compare the two. Every keeper has raised them either one way or the other. What this proves is two things. First, that we cannot seem to raise these animals successfully on either diet. Second, that there is proof for neither diet.
To scientifically disprove one or the other would require a keeper who had raised animals in similar situations on multiple diets (to show the variables) and then shown that one was lacking. There is evidence that both diets could be problematic, however there is not enough to disprove either. Where this leaves us is that it seems to be a personal choice on which one to feed. Im sure we all know by now where we each stand on this choice so everything else is a little academic at this point.
The most useful thing I have gleaned from this debate is that we have to pay more attention to what we are giving our feeders. Typical farm mice are high in fat. Typical farm insects are low in minerals. Mice become healthier if raised on a natural diet (not dogfood) and insects/inverts become vastly better reared on a nutritious diet. Those things are proved, and therefore proven to be better for Savannah monitors.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|