border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Community Forums > General Discussion

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 08-05-17, 04:54 AM   #1
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by dannybgoode View Post
By coincidence we were having the same debate on a Facebook group. The following is from Fran Baines.

For those that don't know of Fran she is a world leading scientist on reptile heating and lighting. Zoos around the world consult her and she has published hundreds of papers on the subject.

She is hunting out some papers from her library on the need for snakes to thermoregulate and as soon I have then I'll post a link.

If Fran says they need to thermoregulate I'll take her word over that over any number of breeders and hobbiests to be honest - she's done the research.

---
All reptiles need to thermoregulate for optimum health; they need to be able to adjust their internal body temperature according to their current physiological need. This includes an increase in body temperature when digesting food, for example. And a night drop is important (along with darkness) to regulate circadian rhythms.
Ideally, you're looking to create a thermal gradient that's above the average preferred body temperature at one end of the vivarium, as a heat source, and cooler than the preferred body temperature at the other end, as a "heat sink" (technical term for cooling-off place)...
Unfortunately if you keep the whole environment at the same temperature, the reptile can't change its body temperature at all. This is chronic stress, and can lead to poor health and poor growth.
---

This from Francis Cosqueiri - a herpetologist who's spent decades observing snakes.

---
You may not know this but Fran is a world renowned vet whose advice is sought by zoos and institutions worldwide, that has published reams of peer reviewed papers, especially on the topic she is advising on - she doesn't give "opinions" she changes the way these animals are viewed with her work. The wise would do well to sit up, shut up and pay heed when she givrs advice.

Also, yes - keeping a reptile at one temperature is absolutely terrible advice, bordering on cruelty in my opinion, regardless of the "loads of people" that say otherwise. Simply because the preferred temperature (Tp) of these animals has been shown to vary depending on age, season, gender... In fact some of my own research was on preferred temperature in reptiles and I can even name cryptic species that have been separated due to their preference for different temperatures!

Providing a thermal gradient is ALWAYS to be recommended, even for hardy Royal Pythons, because that is how these animals thermoregulate. It is essentially the basic building block of ethical reptile care.
---

As I say when Fran gives me the papers I'll post them up.
My source is the curator of the Reptile Gardens and has just as much experience. I have to say once again that there is more than one way to skin a cat.
jjhill001 is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 08-05-17, 05:09 AM   #2
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by jjhill001 View Post
My source is the curator of the Reptile Gardens and has just as much experience. I have to say once again that there is more than one way to skin a cat.
Have they had peer reviewed papers published on the subject?

If the science shows they need to thermoregulate that is it as far as I'm concerned regardless of anecdotes.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-06-17, 10:06 AM   #3
RAD House
Member
 
RAD House's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec-2014
Location: Denver
Posts: 839
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Danny, from both those quotes it sounds as if they are sharing opinions. Neither reference any work that shows their opinion holds validity. I will concede their opinion comes from a ton of experience, but that doesn't mean they have any experience keeping snakes at a stable temperature.
__________________
R.A.D. house
RAD House is offline  
Old 08-06-17, 10:40 AM   #4
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by MesoCorney View Post
Danny, from both those quotes it sounds as if they are sharing opinions. Neither reference any work that shows their opinion holds validity. I will concede their opinion comes from a ton of experience, but that doesn't mean they have any experience keeping snakes at a stable temperature.
Fran has spent decades researching reptile heating and lighting - much of it in lab conditions. She is a world renowned reptile vet who consults with the world's top zoos. She has published hundreds of scientific peer reviewed papers. I would say hers, whilst possibly just 'opinion', is far more informed than any of ours. And note as a scientist - if the evidence suggested that a single stable temperature as optimum that is what she would promote.

Francis' research is interesting as he has had to separate snakes of the same species as they had different temperature preferences the suggesting that if we find a single temperature on every multiple snakes of the same species, never mind separate species, some of these snakes may be at a sub optimal temperature.

I think aside from whether a single temperature of thermoregulation is any better than one another the fact is we simply do not know what (if there even is one) this magic temperature is for an individual snake - nevermind multiple snakes.

In humans if the core temperature deviates by more than a couple of c either way the body shuts down. So a degree of two difference in a snake temperature may be biologically very significant. How do we know therefore that it should be 26, 27, 28c - whatever. We simply don't. By keeping snakes at a single temperature you are picking an arbitrary temperature and knowing that on your snakes giving them no choice in the matter. How can this be justifiable?

Further how do we know that even if through thermoregulation a snake only changes its internal temperature by 0.5c each way this isn't significant? Again to remove this choice - to me at least - seems unnecessary. In in lieu of knowing for certain - given its a relatively trivial thing to do why not provide a basking spot and the chance to thermoregulate.

I have been given 6 or so papers on the subject of thermoregulation in snakes which I am currently saying through and then I'll post them up - hopefully with a coherent brief summary of each one.

I would of the challenge out there to find papers in support of single temperature keeping.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus

Last edited by dannybgoode; 08-06-17 at 10:55 AM..
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-06-17, 11:21 AM   #5
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

And as well as papers my other request is to tell me at what single temperature ensures should be kept and on what days and other research this figure is based on.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 08-06-17, 11:54 PM   #6
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

For being the world leading scientist on reptiles I can't find a single result on google, typing her name in. You don't need someone to publish it in a journal to see results.

I would challenge that she probably never kept a snake at a single temperature in order to see if there is any measurable difference. I also maintain that the majority of studies are done with the goal of understanding wild aninals more meaning that they obviously would try and replicate those conditions.
jjhill001 is offline  
Old 08-07-17, 02:14 AM   #7
TRD
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2016
Posts: 715
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by jjhill001 View Post
For being the world leading scientist on reptiles I can't find a single result on google, typing her name in. You don't need someone to publish it in a journal to see results.
Type the right name: Frances M Baines

And it's not on reptiles, it on lighting requirements for reptiles.
TRD is offline  
Old 08-07-17, 02:23 PM   #8
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by TRD View Post
Type the right name: Frances M Baines

And it's not on reptiles, it on lighting requirements for reptiles.
Who the heck is "Francis Cosqueiri" then? Lol.
jjhill001 is offline  
Old 08-07-17, 05:01 PM   #9
TRD
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2016
Posts: 715
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by jjhill001 View Post
Who the heck is "Francis Cosqueiri" then? Lol.
Just a very knowledgeable dude from the UK that has brought many colubrid snakes into Europe back in the days and is still working on establishing new species in captivity. He keeps quite a lot of snakes people don't usually keep in very nice setups and maintains a whole bunch of articles related to husbandry. Nice guy as well. And no, you won't find him all over internet
TRD is offline  
Old 08-07-17, 12:50 AM   #10
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

So essentially you're advising people it's fine to deny a snake the ability to perform one of its fundamental behaviours with no scientific understanding of the importance of that behaviour and with no research or data to back up or prove what this magic temperature is or even be able tell me what it is?

You have no proof either that different species are all ok at the same temperature (and I can categorically say this is not the case).

But hey some snakes haven't died yet and some have even bred so it must be ok. The default position of people who follow breeder methodology (and I am not making just on here but in the hobby in general) is to demand papers from those advocating an alternate position.

As I say I have 6 or so papers on the subject, one of which does indeed compare snakes being allowed thermoregulate against those kept at a single temperature.

I am simply asking for the same. What scientific proof do you have that your method is not harmful - what proof do you have that denying a fundamental behaviour is ok?
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 08-07-17, 03:19 PM   #11
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by dannybgoode View Post
So essentially you're advising people it's fine to deny a snake the ability to perform one of its fundamental behaviours with no scientific understanding of the importance of that behaviour and with no research or data to back up or prove what this magic temperature is or even be able tell me what it is?

You have no proof either that different species are all ok at the same temperature (and I can categorically say this is not the case).

But hey some snakes haven't died yet and some have even bred so it must be ok. The default position of people who follow breeder methodology (and I am not making just on here but in the hobby in general) is to demand papers from those advocating an alternate position.

As I say I have 6 or so papers on the subject, one of which does indeed compare snakes being allowed thermoregulate against those kept at a single temperature.

I am simply asking for the same. What scientific proof do you have that your method is not harmful - what proof do you have that denying a fundamental behaviour is ok?
First off, I'm not advising anyone to do anything. If something is working for them then why would they change it?

I also don't like the implication that I don't understand that some snakes bask in the wild or why they do it.

I've said that the temperature is in the 80 degrees F +/- a degree or two.

Some snakes? There are probably upwards of tens of thousands of snakes being kept in this manner with no ill effects. So many snakes have been kept this way and many different species.

You say you have 6 papers on the subject, you haven't posted any of them. This is you saying "I have a source and its a better source than yours just because I said so." There aren't many papers on the subject because very few people in the scientific community care about captive husbandry. Who would I go to in order to gain funding for such a long term and potentially costly study? Reptile care product companies wouldn't fund such a study at the risk of losing customers for their heating products and the scientific community probably just doesn't care. I only have my experiences with this method and the evidence that others have produced who do something similar.

I won't be encouraged to do something that adds an unnecessary variable to my enclosures that isn't offering any measurable benefit but has the risk to cause issues. If my snakes were listless or experiencing any kind of issues I would change it immediately but that's just flat out not the case. This method works as well as any other method does when done correctly for the same reason those methods work.

In regards to taking away their behaviors, I don't feel as if I'm stopping my snake from exploring it's enclosure, the many tunnels through the substrate prove that they remain as active as ever.

Anyways I've given my reasoning behind why I do what I do already, have a good evening.
jjhill001 is offline  
Old 08-08-17, 08:30 AM   #12
Aaron_S
Forum Moderator
 
Aaron_S's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov-2002
Location: Toronto
Age: 41
Posts: 16,978
Send a message via MSN to Aaron_S
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by dannybgoode View Post
So essentially you're advising people it's fine to deny a snake the ability to perform one of its fundamental behaviours with no scientific understanding of the importance of that behaviour and with no research or data to back up or prove what this magic temperature is or even be able tell me what it is?

You have no proof either that different species are all ok at the same temperature (and I can categorically say this is not the case).

But hey some snakes haven't died yet and some have even bred so it must be ok. The default position of people who follow breeder methodology (and I am not making just on here but in the hobby in general) is to demand papers from those advocating an alternate position.

As I say I have 6 or so papers on the subject, one of which does indeed compare snakes being allowed thermoregulate against those kept at a single temperature.

I am simply asking for the same. What scientific proof do you have that your method is not harmful - what proof do you have that denying a fundamental behaviour is ok?
I definitely think she has merit and I appreciate you posting her words here for us. I personally prefer the gradient because I don't like the idea of the ideal temp. I think it takes more work, a more dedicated room and if a rack isn't full of snakes I can just pull the plug on the heat tape whereas with the room I have to keep the heat constant.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jjhill001 View Post
First off, I'm not advising anyone to do anything. If something is working for them then why would they change it?

I also don't like the implication that I don't understand that some snakes bask in the wild or why they do it.

I've said that the temperature is in the 80 degrees F +/- a degree or two.

Some snakes? There are probably upwards of tens of thousands of snakes being kept in this manner with no ill effects. So many snakes have been kept this way and many different species.

You say you have 6 papers on the subject, you haven't posted any of them. This is you saying "I have a source and its a better source than yours just because I said so." There aren't many papers on the subject because very few people in the scientific community care about captive husbandry. Who would I go to in order to gain funding for such a long term and potentially costly study? Reptile care product companies wouldn't fund such a study at the risk of losing customers for their heating products and the scientific community probably just doesn't care. I only have my experiences with this method and the evidence that others have produced who do something similar.

I won't be encouraged to do something that adds an unnecessary variable to my enclosures that isn't offering any measurable benefit but has the risk to cause issues. If my snakes were listless or experiencing any kind of issues I would change it immediately but that's just flat out not the case. This method works as well as any other method does when done correctly for the same reason those methods work.

In regards to taking away their behaviors, I don't feel as if I'm stopping my snake from exploring it's enclosure, the many tunnels through the substrate prove that they remain as active as ever.

Anyways I've given my reasoning behind why I do what I do already, have a good evening.
Now, if you haven't seen it, Danny mentioned she's a world renowned vet. She's a "for profit" person so she could fund her own studies. However, someone who has a business in some respect has an agenda for their own gain in my opinion but it doesn't mean we can't dig further into the conversation because she could easily be right and her papers, when they're posted, could be very insightful.
Aaron_S is offline  
Old 08-08-17, 02:44 PM   #13
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aaron_S View Post
Now, if you haven't seen it, Danny mentioned she's a world renowned vet. She's a "for profit" person so she could fund her own studies. However, someone who has a business in some respect has an agenda for their own gain in my opinion but it doesn't mean we can't dig further into the conversation because she could easily be right and her papers, when they're posted, could be very insightful.
I misread where he said Fran Baines and only saw the Francis Cosqueiri name, so that's my bad. I get on here pretty late some times and the similarity of the first name must have done it.

Terry Phillip is a world renowned snake keeper and zoo curator. Looking at how much he's been involved in conservation, documentaries and research he's just as much of an authority as anyone else who's referenced in regards to snake care as far as I'm concerned.

"Because of my experience and reputation among the worldwide venomous community, I also train both private and professional venomous snake keepers on handling techniques, captive management, and husbandry protocol - I have had the opportunity to train keepers and curators from San Diego, the St. Louis, Henry Doorly Zoo in Omaha, the Denver Zoo, the zoos in Dallas and Ft. Worth, the Woodland Park Zoo in Seattle, Miami MetroZoo, and the Tampa Zoo."

The link to his site is below included in his about me section.

About Me | Black Hills Pythons | Rapid City, South Dakota

The point I'm trying to make is that I'm not just pulling stuff out of my butt to defend the way I'm doing things. The same way that Danny isn't pulling anything out of his butt. I don't feel he's wrong however I don't think that I am either. Which goes back to my statement about there being more than one way to take care of snakes.
jjhill001 is offline  
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:19 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right