border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Python Forums > General Python Forum

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-11-13, 09:53 AM   #16
poison123
Member
 
poison123's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul-2012
Location: Pluto
Posts: 1,705
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by Derek Roddy View Post
It's common snake biology. Look it up.


D
Can you point me in the right direction? I cant find any scientific evidence of this.

I know they don't have limbic systems which is where mamals emotions come from but reptiles are not mammals. There was a convo like this on another forum I personally don't believe reptiles have all the same emotions as us humans but they do have the ability to fear so who knows what else they have. I was hoping that you had scientific proof to support my claims as well.
__________________
Daniel

Last edited by poison123; 05-11-13 at 10:07 AM..
poison123 is offline  
Old 05-11-13, 10:04 AM   #17
Derek Roddy
Member
 
Derek Roddy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2013
Posts: 620
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Yeah, you could start with a book called "vertebrates" by kardong. It's a good book to have all around.
It shows the different parts of the body of most verts (including the brains) and what they're capable of from species to species based on the way they're brains are built.

Or you could search "parts of the brain"....learn what they do and compare to the snakes brian and, what it would be capable of based on it's simplistic design.

Cheers,
D
Derek Roddy is offline  
Old 05-11-13, 10:14 AM   #18
poison123
Member
 
poison123's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul-2012
Location: Pluto
Posts: 1,705
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by Derek Roddy View Post
Or you could search "parts of the brain"....learn what they do and compare to the snakes brian and, what it would be capable of based on it's simplistic design.

Cheers,
D
So compare humin brains with reptiles? I don't think thats a good idea. Again reptiles may store their emotions else where compared to that of a human. We still have a lot to learn about the reptile brain.

I'll look into that book.
__________________
Daniel
poison123 is offline  
Old 05-11-13, 10:28 AM   #19
Derek Roddy
Member
 
Derek Roddy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2013
Posts: 620
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by poison123 View Post
So compare humin brains with reptiles? I don't think thats a good idea. Again reptiles may store their emotions else where compared to that of a human. We still have a lot to learn about the reptile brain.

I'll look into that book.
I didn't say compare with a human brian....I said brain..any brian pick one.

They all function the same provided they have the same parts. Animals that don't have those parts don't use those functions. That's a scientific fact.

Snakes don't fear, nor are they happy. They maybe "threatened" but, threat doesn't = fear. Defense is a natural evolved reaction..fear is learned behavior.

I'll give you an example...
My Green Tree Pythons guards their water bowl at night waiting for prey to come drink.
They didn't "learn" that their prey need to drink water from being my cage it's whole life.
That's a built in evolutionary trait. So, is defending itself.
Defense has nothing to do with fear.

D
Derek Roddy is offline  
Old 05-12-13, 11:19 AM   #20
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

I dont think its quite that simple, Derek. Whenever discussing something as plastic as the brain, its hard to talk in any kind of absolutes. What is being discovered recently is that the assumptions about the function of various parts of the brain across species are having to be reevaluated. The evidence seems to indicate that reptiles, birds, etc use parts of their brains for functions and behaviours other than we use those parts of the brain for. Beyond this, it has been shown that reptiles also display lateralized brains, a very important discovery in better understanding the scope of function in reptile brains, and further evidence that reptile brains are much more developed than previously thought. What's more, there is very good evidence of learned behaviour in reptiles. Think of the extensive mapping required for home territories of various lizards, for instance.

Its an interesting subject, and one worth looking into further.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 05-12-13, 11:49 AM   #21
Pirarucu
Member
 
Pirarucu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2012
Posts: 2,054
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I dont think its quite that simple, Derek. Whenever discussing something as plastic as the brain, its hard to talk in any kind of absolutes. What is being discovered recently is that the assumptions about the function of various parts of the brain across species are having to be reevaluated. The evidence seems to indicate that reptiles, birds, etc use parts of their brains for functions and behaviours other than we use those parts of the brain for. Beyond this, it has been shown that reptiles also display lateralized brains, a very important discovery in better understanding the scope of function in reptile brains, and further evidence that reptile brains are much more developed than previously thought. What's more, there is very good evidence of learned behaviour in reptiles. Think of the extensive mapping required for home territories of various lizards, for instance.

Its an interesting subject, and one worth looking into further.
This. Also, it seems to me that you are referring to the fact that snakes lack the part of the brain that we think controls emotions in mammals. There are a few problems with the conclusion you have drawn. For the sake of argument, let's assume that that is really the part of the brain that controls emotions, as has been theorized.
Firstly, it controls the emotions felt by mammals. Do you really think they couldn't have evolved a different way to feel emotions, perhaps entirely diffeirent from the ones we are capable of feeling? Birds and insects evolved wings separately and they are very different in structure, but they both accomplish the same purpose. Perhaps to them, we are the ones who do not display emotions..
Secondly, you are talking about emotions, which are not quite the same as preference. Remorse, loyalty, and complex emotions are not in the same area as displaying preference backed by reason or instinct. Put a snake in a cage that is half natural and half sterile and see which side it uses.. We also see very frequently snakes that prefer one variety of prey over another. It's one thing to say that they don't display affection or sorrow in the sense that we can comprehend,but it's quite another to say they are unable to display any sort of complex behavior such as preference, especially when we see it all the time.
Pirarucu is offline  
Old 05-14-13, 07:15 AM   #22
Derek Roddy
Member
 
Derek Roddy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2013
Posts: 620
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I dont think its quite that simple, Derek.
Of course it's not that simple but, it's science and that's what we know. Until it is rewritten.....that's what I go by.

Conditioning is different than actually learning. I guess you could say that conditioning is the basis for learning but, conditioning can easily be effected by one outside source.

For instance, the test in which a scientist took corns snakes and "conditioned" them to know where a safe place was. That's all fine and dandy....until you add food to the equation. The animal will choose food over safety....every time.
And that...overrides what was "learned"....making it not an actual learned behavior but, a conditioned one.
Snakes don't know that crossing a busy road could kill them...even though they've been doing it for as long as we've had roads. You'd think that if they could learn anything at all in all that time....it would be to go around or wait til traffic has passed.

Can reptiles be conditioned? Absolutely.

But, they can't "learn" not to cross roads because they might get killed. Again, something (mating, food, etc) over rides that "conditioned" response.
They simply don't have the "brain power".

It's very easy to see what they know and don't know how to do....just watch em.

D
Derek Roddy is offline  
Old 05-14-13, 07:17 AM   #23
Derek Roddy
Member
 
Derek Roddy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2013
Posts: 620
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pirarucu View Post
Put a snake in a cage that is half natural and half sterile and see which side it uses..
I have.....and, it used both equally.

D
Derek Roddy is offline  
Old 05-14-13, 09:14 AM   #24
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Quote:
Originally Posted by Derek Roddy View Post
Of course it's not that simple but, it's science and that's what we know. Until it is rewritten.....that's what I go by.

Conditioning is different than actually learning. I guess you could say that conditioning is the basis for learning but, conditioning can easily be effected by one outside source.

For instance, the test in which a scientist took corns snakes and "conditioned" them to know where a safe place was. That's all fine and dandy....until you add food to the equation. The animal will choose food over safety....every time.
And that...overrides what was "learned"....making it not an actual learned behavior but, a conditioned one.
Snakes don't know that crossing a busy road could kill them...even though they've been doing it for as long as we've had roads. You'd think that if they could learn anything at all in all that time....it would be to go around or wait til traffic has passed.

Can reptiles be conditioned? Absolutely.

But, they can't "learn" not to cross roads because they might get killed. Again, something (mating, food, etc) over rides that "conditioned" response.
They simply don't have the "brain power".

It's very easy to see what they know and don't know how to do....just watch em.

D
If a reptile chose food over safety every time, we wouldn't hear complaints here constantly of "my snake stopped eating". They often choose safety over food. And as for crossing the road, well I suppose I would ask you how many humans are killed on the roads each year. Apparently we don't learn either. What youre calling conditioning and learning is actually the difference between linear and abstract thought, and its relatively new even in human history. What you're doing is trying to maintain a separation based on perspective, and scientists did it for years. There used to be so many things that were exclusively human or animal, with learning vs instinct being a major one. Those lines started breaking down awhile ago though, and will continue to. The aim of science has always been to understand perspective in knowledge, and there are few subjects where that is as difficult to achieve as learning and behaviour.

There are numerous examples of reptiles learning though, with extensive geographical mapping just being one. Take a look at monitors learning color cues for food rewards, or crocodiles manipulating keepers through behavioral changes. Even frogs, what i would consider one of the dumbest animals around, learn to not eat bees after being stung just once. The evidence is there if you are open to finding it. The most interesting part is that this learning happens for them in areas of the brain other than those we use for this. In other words, form does strictly mean function when discussing the brain. It's a relatively new concept, and an important one.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 05-14-13, 11:07 AM   #25
Derek Roddy
Member
 
Derek Roddy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2013
Posts: 620
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

I totally get what you're saying. I understand biology very well. There are so many variables when talking about this stuff.
I don't necessarily think that a snake that won't eat comes down to only safety. again...variables.Tempature, moisture, etc usually go hand and hand with a snake not eating.
Humans make a choice if we want to do dangerous things...You would think a reptile does this only to the point of which it was programed to do from being a hatchling.
They are discovering new things all the time and, it has been theorized many times about the learning ability of snakes but, in the 3 decades I've been keeping animals in a box (wild and captive born) I've never seen it displayed.

Of course, I'm basing my opinions about these animals based on what I see in my collection.
If I can keep an animal for 20+ years and, it never learns anything other than what it was programed to do (defend it's self if it feels threatened for instance.) it would be safe to say that the animal isn't made to "learn" but, to "adapt" based on the evolutionary process the species had made along the way.
It's the beginning process of learning but, as of yet they haven't proven if they can take that early stage to the next stage with their current brain structure.
You would think they'd "learn" that the cage door coming open didn't mean food every time but, mine haven't. Haha.

Cheers,
D
Derek Roddy is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 05-14-13, 12:27 PM   #26
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Ah, but see they did learn that the door opening means food. Youre assuming that they think it means food every time, but maybe they are just hoping thats the case. Maybe they are really pissed off every time you open the door and dont give them food. Seriously though, you do have to allow for the fact that we may simply be seeing things in human terms and so are so far unable to understand the true function of the snakes capabilities. As an extreme example, its like the past IQ tests that were made by wealthy white people in the 50s, which were used to show poor black people werent as smart. Its a reflection on the test maker as much as it is a reflection of the tested subject.

And would you not say that your snakes have different 'personalities', even within the same species? Probably the most animals of a single species I have owned are BPs, and even kept in practically identical environments they did exhibit some different characteristics from one animal to the next. So its hard to say that there isnt some individual brain function based on learning and manipulation. I know what you mean though, they definitely arent up to the level of any kind of higher mammal in their ability to process novel information. I just think that people automatically assumed things about animals in the past that its taken science a while to get over. Now that its becoming a little more acceptable to think outside that box, I think we will be surprised by what we find.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 05-14-13, 12:49 PM   #27
Derek Roddy
Member
 
Derek Roddy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2013
Posts: 620
Country:
Re: Just a quick point

Again, I hear what you're saying. Nowhere in the conversation did I say that snakes aren't capable of lower level thinking..... You know thinking that fits their brain type. Everything you're discribing to me is lower leveling thinking. The ability to "like" something is beyond the capibility of their brains. There is no evidence anywhere of snakes Showing otherwise. Which was my whole point.

I do have animals that display different behaviors but, nothing in their personality but what I assign to them being the human I am. Haha.

If anything the thought of trying to make these animals more human than they are just shows us more and more that they're just that.... Animals.

Evolution is a beautiful thing because emotion is a handcap in the natural world. We've been here less time than any other animal and as time goes on.... Humans are become less and less emotional driven. Everything that has lead to human distruction outside of natural force have been emotion driven.... The need to selve our weak ego. That all comes with higher level thinkig.... such as liking and loving. A snake just does his thing without all that distraction.

D
Derek Roddy is offline  
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:51 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right