|
Re: Sex determination in Varanids?
There's another reason for the belief that raising monitors together will produce an even number of males and females. It's called statistics. As the number of males and females hatching is roughly even, if you raise two at a time over and over again, on average you will get a high number of 1:1 pairs. Magic!
I'll explain it using coins. If you flip a coin, you have a 50% chance of it landing heads and a 50% chance of it landing tails. If you flip two coins at once, there's a 50% chance of coin 'A' landing heads and a 50% chance of coin 'B' landing tails, so the combined probability is 25%.
There's also a 25% chance of coin 'A' landing tails at the same time coin 'B' lands tails.
And a 25% chance of coin 'A' and coin 'B' both landing heads.
But (and here's the tricky bit), there's also a 25% chance of coin 'A' landing tails and coin 'B' landing heads, giving us another head/tail combo, but different than the first one. In other words, there's two ways we can get a head/tail combo (with either A or B being tails and the other being heads), so the combined probability becomes 50%. Twice as much as either two heads or two tails.
Combine a 50% chance of something occurring with the human tendency to remember patterns and for memory to be easily skewed or influenced, so that we remember the favourable outcomes but quickly forget those that don't fit in with our preconceived ideas and... voila, we have a new theory of monitor social sex changes.
It's a small wonder some people are anti-science, as it'll often spoil a good story with the truth.
By the way, the person that came up with the idea of the monitor social sex changes also happens to think that wild monitor babies bond in the nest, hang out together socially for life and then pair up (even though they are siblings) when they hit reproductive age. Consequently the social sex change was seen as part of a much larger picture. We had many a heated conversation about this (for I think it is hokum).
As for parthenogenic monitors, they aren't hermaphrodites. It's lone females producing male babies.
|