border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Lizard Forums > Varanid

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-26-13, 10:37 AM   #1
smy_749
Member
 
smy_749's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Location: CT
Posts: 3,888
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

This is a very complicated topic, if you want to provide the closest thing to natural environment, you are not providing the fundamental niche, you are providing the realized one. This means including less than optimal conditions at times, predators, sickness, etc. etc. We have to draw the line somewhere at how much of the natural environment we are trying to mimic. Don't forget that nature also tends to have a way of keeping things in balance. If each animal was kept at full capacity, full health (as is desired in captivity/pet keeping), then we would have an overpopulation/exponential growth of different species....Look at what happens when a species is removed from an environment which holds the balance , and placed in a fundamental niche (invasive species such as the cane toad).It wreaks havoc. Summary of my rant, not everything in the wild is ideal for the animal, not everything can be mimicked, nor should everything. Finding the exact place to draw the line between wild and captivity is difficult...too difficult.
smy_749 is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-26-13, 11:07 AM   #2
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by smy_749 View Post
This is a very complicated topic, if you want to provide the closest thing to natural environment, you are not providing the fundamental niche, you are providing the realized one. This means including less than optimal conditions at times, predators, sickness, etc. etc. We have to draw the line somewhere at how much of the natural environment we are trying to mimic. Don't forget that nature also tends to have a way of keeping things in balance. If each animal was kept at full capacity, full health (as is desired in captivity/pet keeping), then we would have an overpopulation/exponential growth of different species....Look at what happens when a species is removed from an environment which holds the balance , and placed in a fundamental niche (invasive species such as the cane toad).It wreaks havoc. Summary of my rant, not everything in the wild is ideal for the animal, not everything can be mimicked, nor should everything. Finding the exact place to draw the line between wild and captivity is difficult...too difficult.

+1 I like this post ^^^^
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 11:28 AM   #3
smy_749
Member
 
smy_749's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Location: CT
Posts: 3,888
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by infernalis View Post
+1 I like this post ^^^^
I'm learning, sitting in EEB animal behavior class atm so my mind is at work (not really, I'm not paying much attention as you can tell)
smy_749 is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 11:46 AM   #4
Mark Taylor
Member
 
Mark Taylor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec-2012
Location: Ledbury
Posts: 1,436
Country:
Send a message via Skype™ to Mark Taylor
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by infernalis View Post
+1 I like this post ^^^^
Do we have rep yet? I think it would be a good idea.
__________________
1.2.22 Bci's 1.0 Corn 1.0 Burm
Mark Taylor is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 03:22 PM   #5
nepoez
Member
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Posts: 438
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by smy_749 View Post
This is a very complicated topic, if you want to provide the closest thing to natural environment, you are not providing the fundamental niche, you are providing the realized one. This means including less than optimal conditions at times, predators, sickness, etc. etc. We have to draw the line somewhere at how much of the natural environment we are trying to mimic. Don't forget that nature also tends to have a way of keeping things in balance. If each animal was kept at full capacity, full health (as is desired in captivity/pet keeping), then we would have an overpopulation/exponential growth of different species....Look at what happens when a species is removed from an environment which holds the balance , and placed in a fundamental niche (invasive species such as the cane toad).It wreaks havoc. Summary of my rant, not everything in the wild is ideal for the animal, not everything can be mimicked, nor should everything. Finding the exact place to draw the line between wild and captivity is difficult...too difficult.
I agree on that. But my point of discussion is not about emulating it 100%. But rather, is it so bad to emulate part of it, e.g. some drier seasons(if you know how dry and how long), and slight scarcity of food(if you know how much is appropriate). And the natural size of them in the wild. Obviously there's no point in emulating predators and diseases, and other things.

I guess, to word it slightly better .... I think it would be interested to find out the difference in life span of a few well kept sav in optimal environment like Infernalis's, against the average life span of a wild sav that's only 2 feet as adult. Including only natural deaths excluding deaths from predators and viruses or other diseases, etc.
nepoez is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-26-13, 04:05 PM   #6
smy_749
Member
 
smy_749's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Location: CT
Posts: 3,888
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by nepoez View Post
I agree on that. But my point of discussion is not about emulating it 100%. But rather, is it so bad to emulate part of it, e.g. some drier seasons(if you know how dry and how long), and slight scarcity of food(if you know how much is appropriate). And the natural size of them in the wild. Obviously there's no point in emulating predators and diseases, and other things.

I guess, to word it slightly better .... I think it would be interested to find out the difference in life span of a few well kept sav in optimal environment like Infernalis's, against the average life span of a wild sav that's only 2 feet as adult. Including only natural deaths excluding deaths from predators and viruses or other diseases, etc.
I'm pretty sure it would be shorter. I don't know what defines a natural death though...They have a way of telling age by cutting off a finger digit and doing some tests on the bone, not sure how it works exactly though.
smy_749 is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 04:12 PM   #7
nepoez
Member
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Posts: 438
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by smy_749 View Post
I'm pretty sure it would be shorter. I don't know what defines a natural death though...They have a way of telling age by cutting off a finger digit and doing some tests on the bone, not sure how it works exactly though.
Natural death as in, did my great grand mother die of cancer, or heart attack, or gout, or high blood pressure? No, she dies of old age, that type of natural death. As best as you can do to keep the body running properly.

I have a feeling the captives will live longer too, sort of like most humans in USA(who take care of their health) live much longer than tribes in Japan or Italy.
nepoez is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 04:22 PM   #8
murrindindi
Member
 
murrindindi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 974
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by nepoez View Post

I have a feeling the captives will live longer too, sort of like most humans in USA(who take care of their health) live much longer than tribes in Japan or Italy.
"

"Tribes" in Japan and Italy, which tribes?
I doubt very much the general population in America lives significantly longer than people in Japan or Italy!?
murrindindi is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 04:30 PM   #9
nepoez
Member
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Posts: 438
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by murrindindi View Post
"

"Tribes" in Japan and Italy, which tribes?
I doubt very much the general population in America lives significantly longer than people in Japan or Italy!?
I did that on purpose to catch your attention
nepoez is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 04:36 PM   #10
murrindindi
Member
 
murrindindi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 974
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by nepoez View Post
I did that on purpose to catch your attention

It got my attention.....
murrindindi is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-26-13, 04:18 PM   #11
murrindindi
Member
 
murrindindi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 974
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by nepoez View Post
I agree on that. But my point of discussion is not about emulating it 100%. But rather, is it so bad to emulate part of it, e.g. some drier seasons(if you know how dry and how long), and slight scarcity of food(if you know how much is appropriate). And the natural size of them in the wild. Obviously there's no point in emulating predators and diseases, and other things.

I guess, to word it slightly better .... I think it would be interested to find out the difference in life span of a few well kept sav in optimal environment like Infernalis's, against the average life span of a wild sav that's only 2 feet as adult. Including only natural deaths excluding deaths from predators and viruses or other diseases, etc.

Hi, who told you wild Savannah monitors only reach 2 feet in ToL (over their whole range)?
When you say "if you know how dry and how long, and a slight scarcity of food if you know how much"? Why would you need work that out to any great degree (you can have higher ambient temps and reduce food intake easily at any time). Are you suggesting that keeping them supported 24/7 might be bad for them, if so, in what way?
murrindindi is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 04:25 PM   #12
nepoez
Member
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Posts: 438
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by murrindindi View Post
Hi, who told you wild Savannah monitors only reach 2 feet in ToL (over their whole range)?
When you say "if you know how dry and how long, and a slight scarcity of food if you know how much"? Why would you need work that out to any great degree (you can have higher ambient temps and reduce food intake easily at any time). Are you suggesting that keeping them supported 24/7 might be bad for them, if so, in what way?
- From the book "Truth about savannah monitors". whole length
- I am referring to how long the dry seasons are in say, Ghana, how much food they really get in the wild, etc.
- I am indeed suggesting that keeping them supported 24/7 365d as compared to their less than "ideal" env in the wild is an unknown factor and am curious about anyone's thoughts, or if they have actual comparisons of the 2
nepoez is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 04:56 PM   #13
murrindindi
Member
 
murrindindi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 974
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by nepoez View Post
- From the book "Truth about savannah monitors". whole length
- I am referring to how long the dry seasons are in say, Ghana, how much food they really get in the wild, etc.
- I am indeed suggesting that keeping them supported 24/7 365d as compared to their less than "ideal" env in the wild is an unknown factor and am curious about anyone's thoughts, or if they have actual comparisons of the 2
The problem is that the overwhelming majority of captive Savannah monitors (or any other species) are NOT kept supported at all, let alone 365 days a year, so it would be extremely difficult to find enough long-lived specimens to make a comparison. Also, where are the detailed studies on longevity of this or other species in the wild?
We need to know why they (V. exanthematicus) greatly reduce activity during the dry season/s, I`m not sure that`s too clear (it seems they don`t brumate)?
murrindindi is offline  
Old 03-26-13, 05:34 PM   #14
smy_749
Member
 
smy_749's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Location: CT
Posts: 3,888
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Science is too complicated, with far too many unexplained, undiscovered reasons for why animals do things. Don't over think it and do what works
smy_749 is offline  
Old 03-27-13, 06:03 AM   #15
nepoez
Member
 
Join Date: Mar-2013
Posts: 438
Country:
Re: Emulating Wild Sav Growth

Quote:
Originally Posted by smy_749 View Post
Science is too complicated, with far too many unexplained, undiscovered reasons for why animals do things. Don't over think it and do what works
Again, this is more for discussion purposes and not a suggestion to change what the current standards are at

With the lack of knowledge that we have here it's best to keep them the way we know best(e.g. like Infernalis) But I am just curious about whether a sav kept like that would out live a wild sav(excluding obvious variables such as common premature deaths in the wild such as predators or other ifs and buts, discarding off-topic exceptions)
nepoez is offline  
Login to remove ads
Closed Thread

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right