Quote:
Originally Posted by exwizard
Reptile Student, I see nothing hypocritical here. Seems pretty consistent to me, but what do I know?
|
I'm not attacking any one individual's viewpoints. exwizard, I have stated before that I respect your stance on this matter. My comments were meant in a more broad, generalized sense; i.e. I often come across the "all WC animals are bad and to be avoided, and CBB animals are the ONLY way to go" argument all too often, and it simply does not wash with me.
There are advantages and disadvantages to both WC and CB, and as Shaun pointed out, a lot depends on the exact species being discussed. If we were talking about ball pythons and savannah monitors, I would tend to agree with most that regulating/prohibiting importation into the U.S. for the pet trade would solve a lot of problems. A lot less people would be buying them on impulse, and the market for the animals would improve because EVERY specimen would be CBB. The downside is that more WC animals being collected would just go to the skin and food trades instead.
But then we have shaun's example with the rough-scaled python.
And I also hold to my stance on habitat destruction, something that happens globally. Personally, I would rather go out and collect a group of say, eastern box turtles from a nearby bog and stick them in a pen in my backyard rather than leave them there to get pulverized when the bog is smoothed over and turned into a mini mall. What's ethical in that situation? Leave the wild animals in their natural environment, or save them from inevitable doom? Or let's go back to savannah monitors....is it ethical to leave them in Africa where they're just as likely to get collected and turned into a leather wallet or roasted on a spit, or maybe just maybe give one a half chance at surviving in a wood box in captivity as a "pet?"
Again, I'm not attacking anyone's personal stance, and I once more, applaud those who do adhere strictly to CBB stock; just pointing out that in some cases, the issue is not black and white.
With CBB animals, the quality is better, no doubt. But in some species, it means low or no supply.
Not all WC animals are bad. Some of the best herps I have had over the years were WC specimens. I can only recall a few instances with significant issues, and I believe those issues stemmed more from misunderstanding proper husbandry of the species in question, and had little to do with whether or not it was WC or CBB.