border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Community Forums > General Discussion

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-23-12, 03:21 PM   #1
hellosugaree
Member
 
hellosugaree's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Location: Baltimore
Age: 41
Posts: 446
Country:
Re: S.b. 310

Quote:
Originally Posted by StudentoReptile View Post
People call me and other like-minded extremists, and that we're over-reacting. Well, then if we're wrong, then how come these laws keep popping up left and right?

We're extremists? I say, anyone who says the powers-that-be are going to stop after they're done with the giant snakes...is living under a rock and is frighteningly naive. You need to wake up and keep up to date with what is going on. People like you are part of the the problem, mistakenly believing that "well, its about time they started regulating big snakes. As long as it doesn't directly affect little ole me, whatever."
Your comments are overly pointed.

I never said I supported a federal ban of snakes. I simply said that the Ohio thing did not seem particularly unreasonable. Did you happen to read any of it, or did you simply oppose it because you feel it will lead to unreasonable things later even if it isn't unreasonable to begin with?

I also never said it's about time they started regulating big snakes, I just said I can see where they are coming from when this whole thing got started. There have obviously been problems with them, and even you can't deny that. Opposing legislation that is not unreasonable just because you say it will lead to legislation that is unreasonable is not a very strong argument. Since you seem to be the master of judging naivety, please tell me: is that not naive? How can you expect the other side not to take an all or none approach when that is the same approach you condone? Is that not naive? Furthermore, you previously stated: "I don't see how it is fair to categories leopard geckos, ball pythons and tortoises along with lions, tigers, and bears." Since you brought up the topic of naivety, I find it extremely naive to make this ridiculous conclusion that could not be farther from the truth. If you actually spent 5 minutes reading the bill before jumping to extreme conclusions you might have seen that. Jumping to wild conclusions about things without even making an effort to understand what they are about, in my opinion, fits the definition bill for naive and living under a rock--the very same things you said about me for not virulently opposing something that seems pretty reasonable.
__________________
1.0 Coastal Carpet Python, 1.0 Irian Jaya Carpet Python, 0.0.2 African Greys, 0.0.1 Senegal, 0.0.1 Mudskipper, 0.1 Wife

Last edited by hellosugaree; 05-23-12 at 03:30 PM..
hellosugaree is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 05-23-12, 03:57 PM   #2
StudentoReptile
Member
 
StudentoReptile's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2012
Location: Alabama
Posts: 1,850
Country:
Re: S.b. 310

Quote:
Originally Posted by hellosugaree View Post
I simply said that the Ohio thing did not seem particularly unreasonable. Did you happen to read any of it, or did you simply oppose it because you feel it will lead to unreasonable things later even if it isn't unreasonable to begin with?
I opposed the version that passed. It had redundancies (among other things, mentioning the already mentioned venomous snakes and the already severely protected Komodo dragon) which demonstrated an extreme lack of preliminary research during the bill's construction. It really had no real foundation for even involving the giant constrictors, when there is no real risk to public safety. I also don't agree with many specific restrictions, either. You can disagree with that, but I really do not care. I genuinely felt it was unnecessary.

I also opposed it because I know USARK and other organizations proposed to amend the bill for more realistic guidelines. For the most part, the officials rejected all of it. This again demonstrates unreasonable behavior from unreasonable govt officials. The bill itself is arguably a domino effect from previous legislation, and I genuinely feel other states may potentially follow suit in Ohio's example.

So to answer your question, I most certainly did oppose it, and that is why.

Quote:
I also never said it's about time they started regulating big snakes,
It was implied. I apologize if I misinterpreted you. This subject is a touchy one with me. Sometimes, I feel like its bad enough that we have a minority of our hobby that's irresponsible. Its even worse when another faction is so willing to roll over and acceot any leglistion that comes our way.

Quote:
I just said I can see where they are coming from when this whole thing got started. There have obviously been problems with them, and even you can't deny that.
(sigh) I could write pages about this one....first let's do a impromptu survey of how many people in the U.S. keep giant snakes and how many serious accidents/deaths have occured as a result of giant snake ownership. We've all heard the statistics. There are so many things the average person can get injured or killed by before a giant snake, take your pick: struck by lightning, bees, dogs, horses, car accidents, the list goes on. I'm not denying that a large 20 ft python is potentially dangerous, but so is a motorcycle or a riding lawn mower for that matter. The realistic danger presented simply does not warrant the severe restrictions.

If by "problems" you are including the invasive Burmese in south Florida, I suggest you take a look at that blog again. The snakes are present in only 3 counties. They are barely surviving, not getting ready to migrate northward to start gobbling up poodles and kindergarters like the media would have us believe. I hope you are not naive enough to believe that.

Quote:
Opposing legislation that is not unreasonable just because you say it will lead to legislation that is unreasonable is not a very strong argument.
Since you and I seem to have different views of what is unreasonable in this matter, let's just agree to disagree on this one, heh?

Quote:
Since you seem to be the master of judging naivety, please tell me: is that not naive? How can you expect the other side not to take an all or none approach when that is the same approach you condone? Is that not naive?
It's naive when the "other side" base their law-making decisions on hysteria, fear-mongering and pseudo-science, and not actual facts. I consider it a little naive (among a few other choice adjectives) when USARK and other herp organizations try to work with officials for a more reasonable approach to the percieved problem based on real facts, and the ideas are outright dismissed.

Quote:
Furthermore, you previously stated: "I don't see how it is fair to categories leopard geckos, ball pythons and tortoises along with lions, tigers, and bears." Since you brought up the topic of naivety, I find it extremely naive to make this ridiculous conclusion that could not be farther from the truth. If you actually spent 5 minutes reading the bill before jumping to extreme conclusions you might have seen that.
I already admitted my mistake for not reading the text from the current bill. If you took 5 minutes to see my first post on the top of the 2nd page of this thread, you would see this.
__________________
www.MDCrabtree.com
StudentoReptile is offline  
Closed Thread

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right