|
|  |
| Notices |
Welcome to the sSnakeSs community. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today! If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
|
03-17-12, 07:54 PM
|
#1
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis
I wouldn't call it a theory, rather idle speculation; I only ever caught one in woodland and it had rodent fur in its feces. It was one of the strangest days of my life and it's quite possible that the rodent fur was as unusual as everything else that happened on that day. I didn't go back and as far as I'm aware nobody else has looked (although I'm still waiting, not with bated breath, for these other papers about wild savannah monitors that barelybreathing made reference to). I don't think lizards have the luxury of picking the prey types that contain the best mix of nutrients, they eat what they can compete for. In the grasslands that doesn't seem to include rodents. It would make sense if females were looking for different prey types to males but as far as I am aware that hasn't been demonstrated in any monitor lizard. Females are usually much harder to find than males (I think they take fewer risks) and this difference in behaviour might also be reflected in their diet. No idea how seasonal behaviour differs between the two areas either!
|
I have to disagree with the idea that lizards don't have the ability, or luxury as you called it, to pick their prey. If we look at what their stomach contents are, there seems to be some uniformity not just in what they eat, but in the general percentages. It shows a correlation with the other studies of stomach contents as well. This can't just be coincidence. And I don't think they just wander around aimlessly searching for anything they can put in their mouths. They hunt, they look in specific places and they seem to chose those places based on trying to find a certain type of prey. Of course if something edible presents itself along the way Im sure they'll eat it, but they seem to hunt in a habitual way. I don't think its beyond reason to think that they are hunting those specific prey for a reason.
If you look at studies of captive animals, this is exactly what they do when given a choice. I know, I know, those are captive animals, but again it seems unlikely that captive animals possess a capacity that wild animals would not. And those captive animals specifically chose prey based on dietary requirements, especially females. Like I said before, there was one particular study by Speake, et all that showed that females chose prey based on the particular fatty acid profiles off of their eggs. Granted it was scincid lizards, but again it seems a pretty easy to use that example to postulate on monitors too.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
03-17-12, 09:03 PM
|
#2
|
|
Member
Join Date: Jan-2004
Location: Australia
Posts: 976
|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
I have to disagree with the idea that lizards don't have the ability, or luxury as you called it, to pick their prey. If we look at what their stomach contents are, there seems to be some uniformity not just in what they eat, but in the general percentages. It shows a correlation with the other studies of stomach contents as well. This can't just be coincidence. And I don't think they just wander around aimlessly searching for anything they can put in their mouths.
|
I think it would depend on the species of monitor, but some monitors are just generalists and eat whatever they can find. If there's a consistency in percentages of food found in their stomach, it's probably a reflection of the availability of those food items. I can recall reading papers on the stomach contents of lace monitors, for example, and what the researchers found is that they were eating just about every meat-based life form they stumbled across, from tiny insects to road-killed kangaroos. In one particular study the researcher was hard pressed finding a correlation between the type of food eaten and the size of the monitor, for the largest lace monitors in his study occasionally ate invertebrates and the smallest lace monitors in his study were found with scavenged kangaroo meat in their stomachs. The proportion was different, of course, and the small monitors were unable to take in whole small mammals such as possums and rabbits, which the larger animals were doing. Otherwise monitors of all size groups were eating a wide variety of prey, from insects to large mammals.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
I know, I know, those are captive animals, but again it seems unlikely that captive animals possess a capacity that wild animals would not.
|
It's important not to confuse capacity with options. Captive monitors often do behave differently from wild monitors, not because their instincts have altered but because their options aren't the same. One thing that's available to captives that isn't usually available to wild monitors is a predictable, steady supply of food. Most wild monitors are lean, hungry beasts and they are highly unlikely to pass up a meal, whereas one often sees images of captives lazily taking food from tongs or even ignoring food in their enclosure, knowing that it'll still be there to be eaten later. That's something you'd rarely see a wild monitor do.
It's true that many wild animals, even non-specialists, develop search images for certain types of food and will ignore others, but that's usually only when that particular food item is in extreme abundance and it is advantageous to concentrate on that food rather than waste time looking for other, harder to find morsels. That's why fly fishing for some species of trout is such hard work - you have to 'match the hatch' and only present flies that look like whatever insect is emerging that particular day, as the trout will be concentrating on those and ignoring everything else. Another example is the behaviour of crows around garter snake dens. Instead of eating the whole snake, as they might normally do, they only eat the livers (which they remove with the precision of a surgeon). When there are that many snakes available, they don't need to eat the whole thing but can afford to concentrate on the most nutritious item.
However, those seasonal abundances, at least ones large enough that they might cause a monitor to concentrate on only one food item, are uncommon and most of the time generalist species of monitors will eat whatever they stumble upon.
|
|
|
03-17-12, 11:07 PM
|
#3
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Quote:
Originally Posted by crocdoc
I think it would depend on the species of monitor, but some monitors are just generalists and eat whatever they can find. If there's a consistency in percentages of food found in their stomach, it's probably a reflection of the availability of those food items. I can recall reading papers on the stomach contents of lace monitors, for example, and what the researchers found is that they were eating just about every meat-based life form they stumbled across, from tiny insects to road-killed kangaroos. In one particular study the researcher was hard pressed finding a correlation between the type of food eaten and the size of the monitor, for the largest lace monitors in his study occasionally ate invertebrates and the smallest lace monitors in his study were found with scavenged kangaroo meat in their stomachs. The proportion was different, of course, and the small monitors were unable to take in whole small mammals such as possums and rabbits, which the larger animals were doing. Otherwise monitors of all size groups were eating a wide variety of prey, from insects to large mammals.
|
True, but this thread is specifically related to exanthematicus, who do not appear to be generalists. Daniel gave a good model, I think, in stating that those monitors that will eat carrion seem to belong to a particular adaptation regarding diet, that other monitors do not belong to. (Please correct me, Daniel, if I am misrepresenting what you said earlier) Carrion traps do not work on savannahs, they do work on lacies. I think that difference is very important.
Yes, the seasonal availability of food will determine the percentages quite a bit, undoubtedly. This does not negate the argument however, as each new season there are multiple prey that become available and not just one. However, if the nutrients of the varying prey are, in each season, shown to be roughly the same in scope and quality, that would be a strong argument that the species was still seeking out a particular group of nutrients.
Quote:
Originally Posted by crocdoc
Its important not to confuse capacity with options. Captive monitors often do behave differently from wild monitors, not because their instincts have altered but because their options aren't the same. One thing that's available to captives that isn't usually available to wild monitors is a predictable, steady supply of food. Most wild monitors are lean, hungry beasts and they are highly unlikely to pass up a meal, whereas one often sees images of captives lazily taking food from tongs or even ignoring food in their enclosure, knowing that it'll still be there to be eaten later. That's something you'd rarely see a wild monitor do.
|
I can only see that type of behaviour being a problem either with diet or habitat. And its severely depressing to think about.
Quote:
Originally Posted by crocdoc
Its true that many wild animals, even non-specialists, develop search images for certain types of food and will ignore others, but that's usually only when that particular food item is in extreme abundance and it is advantageous to concentrate on that food rather than waste time looking for other, harder to find morsels. That's why fly fishing for some species of trout is such hard work - you have to 'match the hatch' and only present flies that look like whatever insect is emerging that particular day, as the trout will be concentrating on those and ignoring everything else. Another example is the behaviour of crows around garter snake dens. Instead of eating the whole snake, as they might normally do, they only eat the livers (which they remove with the precision of a surgeon). When there are that many snakes available, they don't need to eat the whole thing but can afford to concentrate on the most nutritious item.
|
Exactly my point! What you are talking about is selection based on specific nutritional needs rather than calories, because of an abundance of prey. When caloric intake is not the only measure by which prey is chosen, then nutritional content seems to be. This is a situation much like captive animals are looking at. So do we feed these non carrion eaters different than we would feed the generalist carrion eaters? I think so.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
03-17-12, 10:19 PM
|
#4
|
Join Date: Mar-2012
Posts: 68
Country:
|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
I have to disagree with the idea that lizards don't have the ability, or luxury as you called it, to pick their prey.
|
No it's not ability, by luxury I mean the breadth of niche. They are physically capable of it but to do so (be a generalist) would mean them competing direct with lots of different animals for the same prey types, and over evolutionary time that hasn't been feasible for savannah monitors. Their stomach contents are quite uniform and they don't wander about "aimlessly" eating whatever fits in their stomachs. But Nile monitors eat whatever they can swallow and so do lace monitors and all the other generalists monitor species that can be attracted to carrion. The BIG difference between lacies and Nile monitors is the dentition; Nile monitors can be durophagous, but if lacies tried it their magnificent slicing teeth would just snap. What it means is that Nile monitors can (and do) switch between a very generalised diet of animals dead or alive and a diet comprised largely of snails. If there are other foods available they won't bother with the snails, but if need be they can live on snails indefinitely, and they have very few competitors for that sort of food. This durophagous dentition occurs only in Polydaedalus and Philippinosaurus monitor lizards.
It's interesting that you talk about food choice experiments because there's very little literature about it in the context of monitor lizards.
I have tried it myself and the results bore no relation whatsoever to the diets in the wild. So I don't think it's safe to postulate at all about that until there is some evidence. Those are the sort of experiments that anybody who keeps lizards in boxes can do, it would be very interesting to see what happens.
|
|
|
03-17-12, 10:32 PM
|
#5
|
|
Moderator
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis
Those are the sort of experiments that anybody who keeps lizards in boxes can do, it would be very interesting to see what happens.
|
I have seen exanthematicus take rodents over inverts in captivity with my own eyes, and a recent post on another forum there is a member who posted that his sav will take nothing but rodents.
Is it a learned behaviour? that I cannot say nor care to speculate.
When Chomper roamed the property, if it moved, he ate it.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
|
|
|
03-17-12, 11:13 PM
|
#6
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis
No it's not ability, by luxury I mean the breadth of niche. They are physically capable of it but to do so (be a generalist) would mean them competing direct with lots of different animals for the same prey types, and over evolutionary time that hasn't been feasible for savannah monitors. Their stomach contents are quite uniform and they don't wander about "aimlessly" eating whatever fits in their stomachs. But Nile monitors eat whatever they can swallow and so do lace monitors and all the other generalists monitor species that can be attracted to carrion. The BIG difference between lacies and Nile monitors is the dentition; Nile monitors can be durophagous, but if lacies tried it their magnificent slicing teeth would just snap. What it means is that Nile monitors can (and do) switch between a very generalised diet of animals dead or alive and a diet comprised largely of snails. If there are other foods available they won't bother with the snails, but if need be they can live on snails indefinitely, and they have very few competitors for that sort of food. This durophagous dentition occurs only in Polydaedalus and Philippinosaurus monitor lizards.
It's interesting that you talk about food choice experiments because there's very little literature about it in the context of monitor lizards.
I have tried it myself and the results bore no relation whatsoever to the diets in the wild. So I don't think it's safe to postulate at all about that until there is some evidence. Those are the sort of experiments that anybody who keeps lizards in boxes can do, it would be very interesting to see what happens.
|
Absolutely right, the only studies I know of are from 'easier' lizards, not monitors. You mean you have tried this with monitors? What parameters/controls did you set on it? Do you think if both were reduced to a paste this would take away the movement/visual aspects that might effect their appeal? (Im assuming you used live prey, but this might not be true)
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
| Thread Tools |
|
|
| Display Modes |
Hybrid Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:04 PM.
Powered by vBulletin® ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.
|
 |