Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis
This issue came up with a reviewer when I submitted a paper to herp review with a well known monitor breeder. The reviewer wanted it rejected on the grounds that animals kept with unlimited access to heat would have shorter life expectancy because their metabolisms were so high. No denying that, of course candles that burn twice as bright last half as long. But the aim of husbandry (pet animals aside) is to produce offspring and success therefore has to be measured by reproductive output rather than in years of survival
|
Ive thought about this debate for awhile, and I wonder why breeding is the measure we use for monitor husbandry. I know that is the goal with farm animals that are used for food, milk, etc, but reproductive success doesnt seem to figure anywhere else in captive animals. Why is it that we would use that over longevity for monitors? To me its kind of like saying puppy mill dogs are healthier than your house dog.
The instinct to breed is stronger, in many cases, than even the instinct for survival. One possible example of this is female monitors that die because of retained eggs due to no suitable nesting area. In which case, it seems like breeding is the minimum level of measure in showing good husbandry, not the ultimate measure. After reading accounts of how these animals were cared for in zoos through the 70s and 80s, and that they bred in those conditions, I find the idea of offspring as the measure to be questionable. Although, maybe Im oversimplifying here and the measure is breeding to multiple generations or something like that.
As with most good debates, it seems to likely to be a mix of the two. I think we wont be able to say we figured it out until we have lots of old monitors that have bred a high number of offspring.