border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Lizard Forums > Varanid

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-05-12, 06:57 PM   #1
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Where they come from, rodents are very abundant as well Greg, so Im not sure that logic really works.
At the risk of sounding a little bit like a jerk LOL, When was the last time you were in Afirca, more particularly where savannahs live? How do you know how abundant the rodent population is? Also keep in mind that most rodents are nocturnal from that part of the world and the varanids are diurnal. They paths may not cross often if there is in fact an abundance of rodents that share the same habitat.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I was present when someone fed a live mouse to a sav. It was actually the first thing that lead me to question them eating rodents as part of their diet. It didnt seem to me that it was very good at killing it, compared to larger monitors or other reptiles.
You and I have had very different observations then. I have seen it hundreds of times. When I first started keeping monitors, there were no big frozen rodent companies. I will not say that your observation is wrong, just different.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
The fact that they will take it doesnt mean much either.
Actually it does mean a lot. The fact that they will eat rodents without hesitation, even fresh wild caughts, means that they must come into contact with, and feed on rodents.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
They will eat anything you give them, including dog or cat food. I think there is a guy online with videos of them eating scrambled eggs. Doesnt mean that they should be fed those items or that it is the healthiest item to feed them either. Just like their captive environment, we should always try our best to go further towards their best needs. Just because we cant exactly replicate it doesnt mean we give up on trying.
Yes, they will eat anything in captivity. Again this just further proves they are opportunistic as well as specialized. The odd scrambled egg every once in a while would be fine. They will eat eggs if they come across them in the wild. Obviously not cookrd though. LOL

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
As to the comment about replicating their natural diet, here is a thought. We see that savannahs are specialized to a type of prey, but unspecialized within that type of prey group. Here is what I mean. They are specialized invert eaters, however the variety of inverts is not specialized. Often individual savs, with no vertebrates in their stomachs have over 30 different types of inverts in them. To me that says feed them inverts, and keep the variety up!
I agree. However, those different inverts have very different nutritional values. These inverts are also eating plants and animals that are indigenous to the environment. Their gut loads are different from farmed raised brown crickets and such that we offer here. So again, we fall short of providing them with a "natural" diet. I am a huge advocate of a varied diet and it seems you are as well. Crickets, and a couple of different species of roach make up a huge part of our varanids diets. However, we also offer rodents as well. In my opinion, a 40% rodent based 60% is a very good ratio.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Again, Ill make the comparison Ive made many times. I think rodents are a little like bacon. Bacon isnt bad for you in and of itself, but if youre fat its not helping, and I doubt you will ever hear your doctor say, "hey you should eat more bacon"
That is a very poor comparison. Rodents are a whole food item, not a fatty strip of flesh from a certain part of a pig.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis View Post
IIf you spent any time at all looking at the diets of wild monitor lizards you would see that they are often not optimal. I know of populations of biawaks that live largely on toads or ranid frogs; they are skinny and small and full of parasites. There are other populations that feed on turtle eggs, and some that live on human corpses and excrement, roadkill, dead fruit bats in caves. .
Daniel, do not forget about the numerous populations of Varanus salvator that live in and around garbage dumps.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."

Last edited by Gregg M; 03-05-12 at 07:02 PM..
Gregg M is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-06-12, 07:49 AM   #2
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gregg M View Post
At the risk of sounding a little bit like a jerk LOL, When was the last time you were in Afirca, more particularly where savannahs live? How do you know how abundant the rodent population is? Also keep in mind that most rodents are nocturnal from that part of the world and the varanids are diurnal. They paths may not cross often if there is in fact an abundance of rodents that share the same habitat.



You and I have had very different observations then. I have seen it hundreds of times. When I first started keeping monitors, there were no big frozen rodent companies. I will not say that your observation is wrong, just different.



Actually it does mean a lot. The fact that they will eat rodents without hesitation, even fresh wild caughts, means that they must come into contact with, and feed on rodents.



Yes, they will eat anything in captivity. Again this just further proves they are opportunistic as well as specialized. The odd scrambled egg every once in a while would be fine. They will eat eggs if they come across them in the wild. Obviously not cookrd though. LOL



I agree. However, those different inverts have very different nutritional values. These inverts are also eating plants and animals that are indigenous to the environment. Their gut loads are different from farmed raised brown crickets and such that we offer here. So again, we fall short of providing them with a "natural" diet. I am a huge advocate of a varied diet and it seems you are as well. Crickets, and a couple of different species of roach make up a huge part of our varanids diets. However, we also offer rodents as well. In my opinion, a 40% rodent based 60% is a very good ratio.



That is a very poor comparison. Rodents are a whole food item, not a fatty strip of flesh from a certain part of a pig.



Daniel, do not forget about the numerous populations of Varanus salvator that live in and around garbage dumps.
I havent been to Africa for at least five years, but I really dont think we need to argue about whether or not rodents are prevalent in the grasslands and farmlands of western Africa, do we?

Either way, it seems that rather than saying inverts are a poor substitution, we can see that poorly raised inverts are a poor substitution. We know that in the past, before proper nutritional information was known, indeed it would have been difficult to raise a monitor to breeding multiple generations on such poor quality inverts. That you have farm raised crickets and roaches with questionable nutritional content seems like the problem, not feeding inverts themselves.

This is something that is easily remedied with proper nutrition for the feeder insect. You see, we learned as a community that inverts raised properly pass on that nutrition to the predator, so I think it may be time to reconsider your ideas about feeding an all invert diet. Maybe 20 years ago it was true that an all invert diet wasnt nutritious enough. It doesnt seem like it is true now. After much research into these prey items there does not seem to be much nutritional difference regarding vitamins and minerals between the two food items, if raised properly. The main difference seems to be with the fat.

Which brings me to the bacon comparison; I think they are a good comparison because of fat content and quality. Youre right in saying bacon is a fatty piece of meat, and so are farm raised rodents. They are roughly 30% fat (inverts are anywhere from 1% fat to 15% fat by comparison). And just like bacon, they arent the good kind of fat. One of the major differences I have found aside from sheer fat content, is the quality of that fat. Bacon is a source high in saturated fats, and so too are rodents. Inverts and fish are a source of unsaturated and polyunsaturated fats (ie the good kind). So you are taking an animal that is adapted to extremely low levels of saturated fats and giving it a diet of 30% saturated fats. Present scientific data shows that across all animal groups that is not a good thing. (check out your cat's and dog's food, even those are trending towards omega 3 and 6 fats!) Then we go to data that shows that the fats in frozen meat oxidize and degrade quickly and easily (as well as Vitamin E) and you have an even worse nutritional source of fats.

So now it seems like the rodents may be the closer comparison to your 'garbage dump' water monitors regarding a dietary source. What if all this time we have been feeding them meat that just makes them fat, much like a bunch of American kids? American kids breed to generations of grandchildren, and live to be 80 or more sometimes, but I dont think anyone would argue that American children are as healthy as they could be.

You see, no one is saying monitors cant be raised on rodents. What we are saying is that as we learn more, it seems like rodents just arent the best source for them. The idea is that we learn from new information, and I think that applying new information here means we attempt to now feed an all invert diet and see if it works. Thats all Im saying. You say there are no monitors that have been raised on an all invert diet? Great, show me anyone who actually tried recently. Show me someone who tried raising them on healthy nutritious inverts and then failed. I think that you will have a very hard time coming up with those individuals, because we all dislike changing an easy routine. What I see is people who have made the assumption that inverts cant possibly be as nutritious so they arent going to test the theory.

As for the argument that inverts are too hard to raise for a young kid who owns a monitor, thats silly. I presently raise roaches, earthworms, hornworms and just recently crayfish for my monitor. I buy crickets and gutload them for a day before feeding. I have raised rats and mice in the past and have to say that there isnt anything as easy as raising inverts. Good grief, what breeds more than roaches?! Im not sure why people keep saying no young person would be able to do this. The proper nutrition for inverts is cheap and simple as well, so that rules out that argument.

Science is about testing theories and finding out. If you rule out a theory before it even has a chance to be tested then the question is about the closed nature of your mind, not the theory. I have one monitor, so Im testing it. Greg you have many from the sounds of it. Have you ever tried raising a monitor on an all invert diet (and by all invert, I mean a variety of nutritionally raised inverts)? If not, then why not? I think the only real way this debate could ever be put to rest is for someone to raise a group of monitors in identical habitats, with different food sources. If I didnt live in NYC I would do it myself, but real estate is a little pricey here for that (and I dont think my fiancee would take kindly to every square inch of our apartment going towards monitor enclosures...much to my chagrin). What do you think?
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Closed Thread

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right