|
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)
I think maybe you just don't understand the way I write. It was in response to a question "How should you approach handling? Wait for it to come to you or can that only be achieved through daily handling when it doesn't seem too keen on it" well of course they are not keen on it and of course you would have to force them. If you think that's me encouraging people to force lizards into being handled you obviously have a problem with my language, I don't think many other people would interpret it like that. He didn't ask "should I handle my lizard" he asked "will it come to me for handling or will I have to force it?"
I said that savannah monitor lizards do not SHARE burrows with rodents (as far as I am aware). You said they do, and now you say that the reference to this is in the paper(s) that you have seen but can't remember where they are and don't recall the names of the authors exactly.
If you spent any time at all looking at the diets of wild monitor lizards you would see that they are often not optimal. I know of populations of biawaks that live largely on toads or ranid frogs; they are skinny and small and full of parasites. There are other populations that feed on turtle eggs, and some that live on human corpses and excrement, roadkill, dead fruit bats in caves. Those are "natural diets" but nobody in their right mind would recommend them as food for captives. The only way you could possibly feed imported savannah monitors a "natural" diet would be to ship in wild freshly caught prey items from Ghana every week, sprinkled liberally with local soil. You couldn't breed those prey species in the US because the captive raised ones would have a very different chemical composition to the ones in the wild for obvious reasons. Or at least the reasons should be obvious, but I have a feeling it won't be.
I'm not aware of people finding 30+ species of inverts in a single stomach, unless that is from Cisse's work in Senegal. I'm not aware of other field studies of exanthematicus except his and mine, I'm really hoping there are others out there but I find it strange that nobody can actually produce a citation. If you do a field work and you don't find stuff it doesn't mean it doesn't occur, only that you haven't found it. It's not an absolute science but it requires more field work to prove or disprove general theories about diet, not speculation. For this reason I'm getting rather tired of having this argument. You seem incapable of understanding what I write, which might be my fault. I think at this stage you need to produce these mystery papers and details of how the reptile place you work in has raised exanthematicus to F2/F3 on a diet of invertebrates alone. This is revolutionary stuff and if it's true it will show that savannah monitor lizards can be kept indefinitely on such a diet. It won't mean it's the only diet that's suitable for them, but it will mean that the diet you espouse has been proved to work. If anybody else knows of a similar situation let's hear from you. I'm keeping an open mind and waiting for you to produce something substantial to back up your case. Let's see the papers and details of this sensational breeding achievement, then your position will make much more sense. Until the papers and details of this f2/F3 breeding are available I don't think there is much point in continuing this conversation, but I'm looking forward to its resumption.
|