|
|  |
| Notices |
Welcome to the sSnakeSs community. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today! If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
|
02-29-12, 05:30 PM
|
#1
|
|
Member
Join Date: Feb-2012
Location: Manchester, NH
Posts: 876
Country:
|
Re: Boas are in the ban crosshairs
Quote:
Originally Posted by red ink
Can someone explain to me the intricacies of the "bill"... it's all a bit sentsationalised with poems and all at the moment.
1) What are the species in the ban?
2) What does "ban" actually mean legislation wise?
3) Are they actually going to come in and euthanise your pet snakes, as that's what's coming accross with the use of that poem?
|
What i understand is that you can not move any banned snakes across state borders. So everyone who has a banned snake can keep their snake, but if you ever need to move, go across state borders for a vet, etc etc its illegal. The point is to stop people from importing snakes into Florida (essentially) but they already have a state law limiting snakes being imported into the state, so i have no idea what the point is other than political jargon to get reelected.
Snakes that will be marked as "dangerous to wildlife" included:
Burmese python
Indian python
Northern African python
Southern African python
Reticulated python
Boa constrictor
Green anaconda
Yellow anaconda
Beni anaconda
DeSchauensee’s anaconda
the main argument behind this being "stupid" is that all of those snakes cannot survive outside of 3 lower counties in Florida and the most southern tip of Texas, all other states in the US will kill these snakes quickly based purely on the cold nevermind lack of food in many places.
The "argument" for it is based on the ill-informed idea that pet snakes can "get out" and "ruin wildlife" in the same way that only the largest of snakes did for a limited time in Florida. It has been proven that 80-90% of the snakes causing issues in Florida died in the last few years due to "slightly colder winters", everywhere else in the US are significantly colder during the winter than those three counties that were "too cold" the last few years anyway.
__________________
Things that deal with my shenanigans: 1.0 Black Milksnake 1.0, Champagne Ball Python, 0.1 Girlfriend,
2.3 Employees
Last edited by Skumbo; 02-29-12 at 05:37 PM..
|
|
|
02-29-12, 10:02 PM
|
#2
|
|
Wandering Cricket
Join Date: Aug-2010
Location: 149.6 million kms left of a G2V
Posts: 1,776
Country:
|
Re: Boas are in the ban crosshairs
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skumbo
What i understand is that you can not move any banned snakes across state borders. So everyone who has a banned snake can keep their snake, but if you ever need to move, go across state borders for a vet, etc etc its illegal. The point is to stop people from importing snakes into Florida (essentially) but they already have a state law limiting snakes being imported into the state, so i have no idea what the point is other than political jargon to get reelected.
Snakes that will be marked as "dangerous to wildlife" included:
Burmese python
Indian python
Northern African python
Southern African python
Reticulated python
Boa constrictor
Green anaconda
Yellow anaconda
Beni anaconda
DeSchauensee’s anaconda
the main argument behind this being "stupid" is that all of those snakes cannot survive outside of 3 lower counties in Florida and the most southern tip of Texas, all other states in the US will kill these snakes quickly based purely on the cold nevermind lack of food in many places.
The "argument" for it is based on the ill-informed idea that pet snakes can "get out" and "ruin wildlife" in the same way that only the largest of snakes did for a limited time in Florida. It has been proven that 80-90% of the snakes causing issues in Florida died in the last few years due to "slightly colder winters", everywhere else in the US are significantly colder during the winter than those three counties that were "too cold" the last few years anyway.
|
So this version of the "ban" isn't going to take your snakes away, you just won't be able to move them from state lines. Wasn't that the same clause as the previous proposed "ban"?
Does the "ban" abolish the breeding of these snakes within a state?
Will it make breeding these snakes illegal?
|
|
|
02-29-12, 10:14 PM
|
#3
|
|
Member
Join Date: Feb-2012
Location: Manchester, NH
Posts: 876
Country:
|
Re: Boas are in the ban crosshairs
Quote:
Originally Posted by red ink
So this version of the "ban" isn't going to take your snakes away, you just won't be able to move them from state lines. Wasn't that the same clause as the previous proposed "ban"?
Does the "ban" abolish the breeding of these snakes within a state?
Will it make breeding these snakes illegal?
|
No. but it will make selling them across state borders illegal, as well as shipping across borders illegal, which cuts off a ton of customers for a ton of people. This also means any expo you go to has to be from people within your state with these snakes, nobody will be bringing any of these cross border for expos because that's illegal as well.
Honestly, from a pet owners perspective, and not a breeders perspective (though this may hamper my dreams to one day breed BRB's if they keep adding snakes) its not that bad. nobody is going to check all your luggage when you move, and you can easily claim, in the extremely rare chance someone wanted to "get you" for importing a snake into a state, that you purchased the snake within the state, as it isn't even close to illegal to breed any of these snakes, you just cant bring them to other states.
this is actually the same "ban" proposed before, just with more snakes on it (it originally had all these, it was moved down to 3 (i believe, maybe 4?) and that was a "victory" then it was brought back at this on short notice with the full original "9")
__________________
Things that deal with my shenanigans: 1.0 Black Milksnake 1.0, Champagne Ball Python, 0.1 Girlfriend,
2.3 Employees
|
|
|
02-29-12, 10:26 PM
|
#4
|
|
Wandering Cricket
Join Date: Aug-2010
Location: 149.6 million kms left of a G2V
Posts: 1,776
Country:
|
Re: Boas are in the ban crosshairs
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skumbo
No. but it will make selling them across state borders illegal, as well as shipping across borders illegal, which cuts off a ton of customers for a ton of people. This also means any expo you go to has to be from people within your state with these snakes, nobody will be bringing any of these cross border for expos because that's illegal as well.
Honestly, from a pet owners perspective, and not a breeders perspective (though this may hamper my dreams to one day breed BRB's if they keep adding snakes) its not that bad. nobody is going to check all your luggage when you move, and you can easily claim, in the extremely rare chance someone wanted to "get you" for importing a snake into a state, that you purchased the snake within the state, as it isn't even close to illegal to breed any of these snakes, you just cant bring them to other states.
this is actually the same "ban" proposed before, just with more snakes on it (it originally had all these, it was moved down to 3 (i believe, maybe 4?) and that was a "victory" then it was brought back at this on short notice with the full original "9")
|
If that was the case then....
Mate I would say that this "ban" is a non-event. All it's restricting is movement of animals not making the animals themselves "illegal".
1) You can still breed/sell in your state (maybe a chance to create a niche market for the hobby breeder)
2) Levels the playing field for the breeders out there...
3) You can't police what crosses state borders, you can just say you bought it there (as you said)
4) It's not enforceable (this from a licensing experience where I am) as there not even a regulatory body that will be monitoring this. There's no proposed census of your animals, so how would they no what you have and don't have or where the heck you bought it from.
5) No animal is "illegal" so realistically no biggie... I really don't see the state governments monitoring their borders that closely looking for "snakes". Or them knocking at your door saying "hey wait a minute that a new damn snake"
Last edited by red ink; 02-29-12 at 10:34 PM..
|
|
|
02-29-12, 10:46 PM
|
#5
|
|
Member
Join Date: Feb-2012
Location: Manchester, NH
Posts: 876
Country:
|
Re: Boas are in the ban crosshairs
Quote:
Originally Posted by red ink
If that was the case then....
Mate I would say that this "ban" is a non-event. All it's restricting is movement of animals not making the animals themselves "illegal".
1) You can still breed/sell in your state (maybe a chance to create a niche market for the hobby breeder)
2) Levels the playing field for the breeders out there...
3) You can't police what crosses state borders, you can just say you bought it there (as you said)
4) It's not enforceable (this from a licensing experience where I am) as there not even a regulatory body that will be monitoring this. There's no proposed census of your animals, so how would they no what you have and don't have or where the heck you bought it from.
5) No animal is "illegal" so realistically no biggie... I really don't see the state governments monitoring their borders that closely looking for "snakes". Or them knocking at your door saying "hey wait a minute that a new damn snake"
|
Exactly! The thing is just avoiding this going through because none of us want it to "open the floodgates" for instance.
I had a really awesome (and depressing) conversation with a friend at college, shes graduating in a few months and will be going back to norway (not what she was planning on) and needs to find a new home for her ball python (im going to take it in most likely) because of a "similar issue" that eventually sprung a ruling in 1977 (yeah a while ago, but the law still stands.) causing an all encompassing ban on reptile ownership in norway. All captive (even in zoos) offspring must be immediately exported (not sold though) or euthanized by law.
That said, its "estimated" that the "illegal herpiles are in the 100,000's in norway, and over 1,000 have been seized/euthanize (they just freeze them or shoot them to death usually on site) by the norweigan government (i looked into it a bit, there are stories about authorities coming in and not being able to confiscate an animal on technicality, so they "taped off" a mans living room and let the animal starve to death before he was allowed into that part of his house again. Others have come home to their animals out in their front yard frozen to death during the winter, as police get search warrants based on "suspected" ownership of reptiles a lot there, apparently.
take my rant as an example of why we don't want bans to begin, because in 40 years we may be in a country where the police can show up and murder your pets because they're not furry enough.
Keep in mind how heart breaking this is for my friend, she came here to study to become a veterinarian, and mainly wants to focus on reptiles, and because of her visa issues she has to move back to a country where its a felony to posses a reptile (keep in mind 5 months out of the year the average temperate is about -5 there, so these bans were passed purely due to sensationalism and political reasons.)
__________________
Things that deal with my shenanigans: 1.0 Black Milksnake 1.0, Champagne Ball Python, 0.1 Girlfriend,
2.3 Employees
|
|
|
| Thread Tools |
|
|
| Display Modes |
Hybrid Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:12 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.
|
 |