|
|  |
| Notices |
Welcome to the sSnakeSs community. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today! If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
|
12-07-11, 08:40 AM
|
#1
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Ha! I originally left all those parts in, but then took some of them out for effect. So good on you for calling me on it! Its not a great technique and I apologize. But back to the discussion.
We agree on something, and its a good first step. You stated that you know that it is not good to feed a reptile cat food directly. However, you then go on to say that there is a huge difference between feeding it to prey animals and feeding it directly. My question is, what information do you have to back that up? First lets look at what we were talking about specifically - gutloading. By its very definition this is the act of feeding a prey item a certain food and then feeding that prey item to a reptile before it has the chance to digest what is in its gut. So in the case of gutloading with cat food, there would be, in fact, almost no difference between feeding it to the prey item or feeding it directly. Undigested cat food is still just cat food. Second, if you are aware that cat food is a bad food item for reptiles then what would make you want to use it for the prey that they directly eat? Even when digested, the same things that are wrong with cat food will be passed along via the prey item. When it comes to bugs, the old saying "You are what you eat" is really pretty true. Third, what is the motivation for feeding them cat food or defending that position? Again its kind of like the rodent/invertebrate argument with monitors. Sure you could feed them that, no it wont kill them. But why, if you know there are better, more natural things to feed them? Especially when there are so many better items available for just as cheap a price, that can be fed to them. The only answer, once again, is convenience to the keeper. And that becomes a thin argument very quickly. Responsibility overrides convenience every time as a keeper.
I think we all agree that its good to do the once over in all our reptile enclosures each day, taking out any excrement, debris, etc from their environment. If convenience is the only argument, then again, why not just add your roach enclosure to this daily ritual? It only takes a few minutes more, and if the advantage is a healthier reptile then Im not sure if there is much reason for the debate.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
12-10-11, 08:01 PM
|
#2
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2010
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 356
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
Ha! I originally left all those parts in, but then took some of them out for effect. So good on you for calling me on it! Its not a great technique and I apologize. But back to the discussion.
We agree on something, and its a good first step. You stated that you know that it is not good to feed a reptile cat food directly. However, you then go on to say that there is a huge difference between feeding it to prey animals and feeding it directly. My question is, what information do you have to back that up? First lets look at what we were talking about specifically - gutloading. By its very definition this is the act of feeding a prey item a certain food and then feeding that prey item to a reptile before it has the chance to digest what is in its gut. So in the case of gutloading with cat food, there would be, in fact, almost no difference between feeding it to the prey item or feeding it directly. Undigested cat food is still just cat food. Second, if you are aware that cat food is a bad food item for reptiles then what would make you want to use it for the prey that they directly eat? Even when digested, the same things that are wrong with cat food will be passed along via the prey item. When it comes to bugs, the old saying "You are what you eat" is really pretty true. Third, what is the motivation for feeding them cat food or defending that position? Again its kind of like the rodent/invertebrate argument with monitors. Sure you could feed them that, no it wont kill them. But why, if you know there are better, more natural things to feed them? Especially when there are so many better items available for just as cheap a price, that can be fed to them. The only answer, once again, is convenience to the keeper. And that becomes a thin argument very quickly. Responsibility overrides convenience every time as a keeper.
I think we all agree that its good to do the once over in all our reptile enclosures each day, taking out any excrement, debris, etc from their environment. If convenience is the only argument, then again, why not just add your roach enclosure to this daily ritual? It only takes a few minutes more, and if the advantage is a healthier reptile then Im not sure if there is much reason for the debate.
|
The difference between gutloading and feeding cat food directly to your reptile is that just the gut is full of the cat food, and you are still getting the nutritional content of the rest of the prey animal. It's the difference between having a pizza with pineapples on top and just eating a pineapple. Good enough analogy? Sure the reptile is getting some catfood, but in a package deal. I don't think cat food is "bad" for reptiles, just in pure form not balanced as eating the prey item... although as we agreed, some preservatives in some brands very much could be bad. With your third argument, I'm not arguing that feeding your roach a balanced diet would be the ideal situation, but at what cost? You have to weigh the benefit against the cost. And again, just feeding the roaches fresh food will nilly is NOT a balanced diet, and I think would be sub-par to cat food.
After all, is it healthier for a person to eat a nasty prepared frozen dinner with a variety of food groups like a TV dinner with veggies, meat, cheese, and grains, or just eat fresh apples all day? Neither is the best solution, the prepared food isn't perfect, but it's pretty balanced, where if you only ate apples, even though they are fresh food items, it's not got everything you need. Come on now... surely there are people here that know a vegetarian/vegan human can be nutritionally sound if they really carefully plan their diet to include everything they need, but the vast majority are depriving themselves of needed nutrients? Same concept applies here. If you are willing to really throw down the time to plan a balanced diet for your roaches, by all means do it! It's just far more complex and time consuming than your average person is going to want to deal with. Otherwise we would all be breeding our own rats fed on a fresh diet (no lab blocks at all, just FRESH food) for snakes rather than buying them from a breeder like rodentpro.
__________________
8.8 resident corns, 0.2 nicaraguan boas, 1.0 ball python
|
|
|
12-12-11, 11:53 AM
|
#3
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by candyraver69
The difference between gutloading and feeding cat food directly to your reptile is that just the gut is full of the cat food, and you are still getting the nutritional content of the rest of the prey animal. It's the difference between having a pizza with pineapples on top and just eating a pineapple. Good enough analogy? Sure the reptile is getting some catfood, but in a package deal. I don't think cat food is "bad" for reptiles, just in pure form not balanced as eating the prey item... although as we agreed, some preservatives in some brands very much could be bad. With your third argument, I'm not arguing that feeding your roach a balanced diet would be the ideal situation, but at what cost? You have to weigh the benefit against the cost. And again, just feeding the roaches fresh food will nilly is NOT a balanced diet, and I think would be sub-par to cat food.
After all, is it healthier for a person to eat a nasty prepared frozen dinner with a variety of food groups like a TV dinner with veggies, meat, cheese, and grains, or just eat fresh apples all day? Neither is the best solution, the prepared food isn't perfect, but it's pretty balanced, where if you only ate apples, even though they are fresh food items, it's not got everything you need. Come on now... surely there are people here that know a vegetarian/vegan human can be nutritionally sound if they really carefully plan their diet to include everything they need, but the vast majority are depriving themselves of needed nutrients? Same concept applies here. If you are willing to really throw down the time to plan a balanced diet for your roaches, by all means do it! It's just far more complex and time consuming than your average person is going to want to deal with. Otherwise we would all be breeding our own rats fed on a fresh diet (no lab blocks at all, just FRESH food) for snakes rather than buying them from a breeder like rodentpro.
|
Your analogy works well about the pizza, because its exactly my point. Pizza isnt healthy! Will it kill you? No. But is it healthy? Again, no not really (unless, like Congress, you believe pizza sauce is a vegetable  ). As to your idea about vegetarians, most of the vegetarians I know are actually much more healthy than I am. The reason is because they pay much more attention to what they eat. So again, thank you for bringing up that point. Will a 'willy nilly' fresh diet improve them? Of course not, but that was never what we were discussing here. Our roaches will be healthier too if we pay more time and attention to what they eat, and therefore they will be healthier food items for our reptiles. Wouldnt it be better to improve the diet of our feeder items so much that we never needed to dust or supplement again? I think its possible.
As to your point about costs, we arent talking a huge difference. Each week I spend about $12 on food in total for around 1000 roaches (today I spent $3 for green beans, $2 for bananas, $1.50 raisins, $3 for kale, $1 for squash and I estimate the amount of cost from their dried food bags to be about $1.50). Now that is here in New York City, where everything is expensive, so Im sure it might even be cheaper for others. I know that feeding them just a bunch of dried cat food is cheaper, maybe only $3 a week or so (Im just guessing here). But if a few bucks a week is too much to improve your animals life, then perhaps we are having the wrong discussion.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
12-13-11, 09:09 PM
|
#4
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2010
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 356
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
As to your point about costs, we arent talking a huge difference. Each week I spend about $12 on food in total for around 1000 roaches (today I spent $3 for green beans, $2 for bananas, $1.50 raisins, $3 for kale, $1 for squash and I estimate the amount of cost from their dried food bags to be about $1.50). Now that is here in New York City, where everything is expensive, so Im sure it might even be cheaper for others. I know that feeding them just a bunch of dried cat food is cheaper, maybe only $3 a week or so (Im just guessing here). But if a few bucks a week is too much to improve your animals life, then perhaps we are having the wrong discussion.
|
When I used the term "costs" I wasn't referring to money at all. I was talking about the time you would take planning the diet, chopping fresh food up each day, etc. The roaches eat so little it's negligent really the dollar amount of the veggies unless you have a TON. Time is money though!
__________________
8.8 resident corns, 0.2 nicaraguan boas, 1.0 ball python
|
|
|
| Thread Tools |
|
|
| Display Modes |
Hybrid Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:29 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.
|
 |