|
|  |
| Notices |
Welcome to the sSnakeSs community. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today! If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
|
12-01-11, 09:14 AM
|
#1
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Im just a new roach breeder, so Im genuinely asking out of curiosity. Perhaps Im not aware of various breeding problems with roaches yet. Im just wondering why the desire to feed dog food or cat food? If what you feed them goes pretty much into your reptiles then the question is, would you feed your reptile dog food or cat food? Or any other processed foods for that matter. My thinking was, if I can I should try to keep it as natural as possible. Ive been feeding them oats (which are super cheap if you buy in bulk, less than a dollar a pound), raisins, and then whatever vegetables happen to be on sale (for the last couple weeks its been green beans). I also cant think of any need for a high protein diet for them. I cant remember any examples I have ever read of any entomophagic reptile having a lack of protein as a nutritional issue. Is there a reason you went with the high protein stuff?
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
12-01-11, 12:18 PM
|
#2
|
|
Retic Fanatic
Join Date: Mar-2011
Age: 37
Posts: 7,119
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
Im just a new roach breeder, so Im genuinely asking out of curiosity. Perhaps Im not aware of various breeding problems with roaches yet. Im just wondering why the desire to feed dog food or cat food? If what you feed them goes pretty much into your reptiles then the question is, would you feed your reptile dog food or cat food? Or any other processed foods for that matter. My thinking was, if I can I should try to keep it as natural as possible. Ive been feeding them oats (which are super cheap if you buy in bulk, less than a dollar a pound), raisins, and then whatever vegetables happen to be on sale (for the last couple weeks its been green beans). I also cant think of any need for a high protein diet for them. I cant remember any examples I have ever read of any entomophagic reptile having a lack of protein as a nutritional issue. Is there a reason you went with the high protein stuff?
|
I have a layer of dog food at the base of my enclosure, sometimes I get busy and don't have time to feed them but my pets who eat them still need to eat, and that way they are always gut loaded.
That being said, when I do make time, they get fresh fruit and believe me you know it when you leave it in there too long lol. The smell punches you in the face, or you breath in a fruit fly.
__________________
People who know everything are often clueless.
|
|
|
12-01-11, 05:50 PM
|
#3
|
|
Veteran Member
Join Date: Aug-2008
Location: Surrey BC
Age: 44
Posts: 2,379
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by stephanbakir
I have a layer of dog food at the base of my enclosure, sometimes I get busy and don't have time to feed them but my pets who eat them still need to eat, and that way they are always gut loaded.
That being said, when I do make time, they get fresh fruit and believe me you know it when you leave it in there too long lol. The smell punches you in the face, or you breath in a fruit fly.
|
lol wet roach poop and rotten fruit is somthing to experience, the horror!!
|
|
|
12-02-11, 03:52 PM
|
#4
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2010
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 356
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
Im just a new roach breeder, so Im genuinely asking out of curiosity. Perhaps Im not aware of various breeding problems with roaches yet. Im just wondering why the desire to feed dog food or cat food? If what you feed them goes pretty much into your reptiles then the question is, would you feed your reptile dog food or cat food? Or any other processed foods for that matter. My thinking was, if I can I should try to keep it as natural as possible. Ive been feeding them oats (which are super cheap if you buy in bulk, less than a dollar a pound), raisins, and then whatever vegetables happen to be on sale (for the last couple weeks its been green beans). I also cant think of any need for a high protein diet for them. I cant remember any examples I have ever read of any entomophagic reptile having a lack of protein as a nutritional issue. Is there a reason you went with the high protein stuff?
|
Because what you feed them goes in to your reptile is precisely why you want high protein (and high calcium for lizards). Don't think of it as a protein deficiency issue as much as, how many roaches does your reptile need to eat to get the right amount of protein and what else is going to come along with that (fat, exoskeleton, etc). You could feed the roaches tofu and steak I suppose if you wanted to be more natural, but cat food works well.
I know I suggested cat food in one dubia thread for gutloading for tarantulas. For lizards you certainly want to add some form of calcium additionally to the cat food, or dust the roaches right before feeding. You can also put jurasical in the water you mix up your water crystals instead to add calcium.
__________________
8.8 resident corns, 0.2 nicaraguan boas, 1.0 ball python
|
|
|
12-03-11, 05:23 PM
|
#5
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by candyraver69
Because what you feed them goes in to your reptile is precisely why you want high protein (and high calcium for lizards). Don't think of it as a protein deficiency issue as much as, how many roaches does your reptile need to eat to get the right amount of protein and what else is going to come along with that (fat, exoskeleton, etc). You could feed the roaches tofu and steak I suppose if you wanted to be more natural, but cat food works well.
I know I suggested cat food in one dubia thread for gutloading for tarantulas. For lizards you certainly want to add some form of calcium additionally to the cat food, or dust the roaches right before feeding. You can also put jurasical in the water you mix up your water crystals instead to add calcium.
|
I suppose that was my worry, so let's go over this in greater detail.
First, my mentioning of protein deficiency was for a point. There is no need to ever worry about the protein intake of your reptile if it is eating any kind of animal, whether invertebrate or vertebrate. Both sources will provide an excess of protein, and your reptile will expel that excess in its waste. This is especially true of invertebrate prey.
Second, increasing the protein in the diet of the roaches will not increase the protein make up of the roach. They too will expel the added protein from their bodies after breaking down the protein into the amino acids they need. But, you are probably now thinking that the advantage comes from the gutloading of cat food in their stomachs. However, gutloading is for vitamins and minerals, NOT for proteins. Which brings us to the next point.
Third, cat and dog food are bad for your reptiles. We all know not to feed our reptiles cat or dog food directly, and with good reason. It's comparable to feeding your children fast food. If we know these are not good to give the reptile directly, then how is gutloading with them good? They are filled with lots of pretty nasty and unhealthy things, as well as lots of preservatives. BHA and BHT are common, as is one very important preservative for this thread, ethoxyquin. I mention that one specifically because it is also commonly used as a pesticide. Roaches have specifically evolved organs to deal with toxins, so while it may not effect them, gutloading for your reptile may likely effect kidney and liver function over time.
I understand that maybe these are small things that aren't going to immediately strike your reptile dead. However, its definitely not a good thing, and if possible, I think should not be common practice. It's also easy to line tubs with oats or other dried grains, or even flour. They're actually cheaper, have plenty of protein, and of course are much more natural. I think for animals, just like people, the least processed, most natural food you can give them is always the best bet.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
|
|
|
12-03-11, 05:48 PM
|
#6
|
|
Retic Fanatic
Join Date: Mar-2011
Age: 37
Posts: 7,119
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
I suppose that was my worry, so let's go over this in greater detail.
First, my mentioning of protein deficiency was for a point. There is no need to ever worry about the protein intake of your reptile if it is eating any kind of animal, whether invertebrate or vertebrate. Both sources will provide an excess of protein, and your reptile will expel that excess in its waste. This is especially true of invertebrate prey.
Second, increasing the protein in the diet of the roaches will not increase the protein make up of the roach. They too will expel the added protein from their bodies after breaking down the protein into the amino acids they need. But, you are probably now thinking that the advantage comes from the gutloading of cat food in their stomachs. However, gutloading is for vitamins and minerals, NOT for proteins. Which brings us to the next point.
Third, cat and dog food are bad for your reptiles. We all know not to feed our reptiles cat or dog food directly, and with good reason. It's comparable to feeding your children fast food. If we know these are not good to give the reptile directly, then how is gutloading with them good? They are filled with lots of pretty nasty and unhealthy things, as well as lots of preservatives. BHA and BHT are common, as is one very important preservative for this thread, ethoxyquin. I mention that one specifically because it is also commonly used as a pesticide. Roaches have specifically evolved organs to deal with toxins, so while it may not effect them, gutloading for your reptile may likely effect kidney and liver function over time.
I understand that maybe these are small things that aren't going to immediately strike your reptile dead. However, its definitely not a good thing, and if possible, I think should not be common practice. It's also easy to line tubs with oats or other dried grains, or even flour. They're actually cheaper, have plenty of protein, and of course are much more natural. I think for animals, just like people, the least processed, most natural food you can give them is always the best bet.
|
Really interesting read. May I ask how the giant glucoseamine argument works with reptiles and muscle density/elasticity?
__________________
People who know everything are often clueless.
|
|
|
12-06-11, 03:26 PM
|
#7
|
|
Member
Join Date: Oct-2010
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 356
Country:
|
Re: Cat food for dubia
Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich
I suppose that was my worry, so let's go over this in greater detail.
First, my mentioning of protein deficiency was for a point. There is no need to ever worry about the protein intake of your reptile if it is eating any kind of animal, whether invertebrate or vertebrate. Both sources will provide an excess of protein, and your reptile will expel that excess in its waste. This is especially true of invertebrate prey.
Second, increasing the protein in the diet of the roaches will not increase the protein make up of the roach. They too will expel the added protein from their bodies after breaking down the protein into the amino acids they need. But, you are probably now thinking that the advantage comes from the gutloading of cat food in their stomachs. However, gutloading is for vitamins and minerals, NOT for proteins. Which brings us to the next point.
Third, cat and dog food are bad for your reptiles. We all know not to feed our reptiles cat or dog food directly, and with good reason. It's comparable to feeding your children fast food. If we know these are not good to give the reptile directly, then how is gutloading with them good? They are filled with lots of pretty nasty and unhealthy things, as well as lots of preservatives. BHA and BHT are common, as is one very important preservative for this thread, ethoxyquin. I mention that one specifically because it is also commonly used as a pesticide. Roaches have specifically evolved organs to deal with toxins, so while it may not effect them, gutloading for your reptile may likely effect kidney and liver function over time.
I understand that maybe these are small things that aren't going to immediately strike your reptile dead. However, its definitely not a good thing, and if possible, I think should not be common practice. It's also easy to line tubs with oats or other dried grains, or even flour. They're actually cheaper, have plenty of protein, and of course are much more natural. I think for animals, just like people, the least processed, most natural food you can give them is always the best bet.
|
Great information. I didn't stop to think about the preservatives. About the protein though, I am going to respectfully disagree. There is a fantastic manual view-able online for free that discusses nutrition in detail, but still there is room for debate as you must consider the difference between 2 roaches with normal diets vs a gutload roach with enough protein in its gut to equal the same protein content. What would the group of two roaches provide that the single roach didn't? Everything that wasn't in the gut would be doubled. So that is what must be considered. What I am talking about isn't increasing protein intake, because to get more protein the animal can just eat more, but increasing the efficiency of getting that protein. Merck Veterinary Manual
So I guess depending what your take on the protein situation is, you might want to consider finding a cat food with less or certain preservatives? Not to say it makes it right because one person does it so everybody should, but think about what kind of diet rodents you feed your snakes have. I can guarantee there are preservatives in most rodent's diets that you feed your snakes. Not many feeder breeders feed their rats/mice anything besides lab blocks, let alone a completely fresh diet.
Certainly if you don't feed cat/dog food you need to feed a balanced fresh diet to your roaches. If you always feed them lettuce or always feed the oranges... the nutrition content is going to plummet. Cat food is convenient because it provides a mix of things in one item. If you are going to do the more natural approach you will need to plan the roaches diet like you would for an iguana, carefully selecting a variety of foods that together contain the needed vitamins, minerals, proteins, etc.
__________________
8.8 resident corns, 0.2 nicaraguan boas, 1.0 ball python
|
|
|
| Thread Tools |
|
|
| Display Modes |
Hybrid Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:18 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.
|
 |