Quote:
Originally Posted by bigsnakegirl785
I certainly could have, but there are less wordy ways to phrase things. Such as what you have done here in this reply. A summary of some sort is usually quite appreciated, and even many academic writings make use of them. Otherwise, you make what you write inaccessible and a little daunting to read.
I'm not necessarily saying cut down on what you write, but offering some sort of summary, review, what have you, is a good way to emphasize certain things and draw attention. Most people aren't just going to read a wall of text for the sake of it, you need to be capable and willing to break it down. This hobby is not filled with academics used to reading and writing academic papers, so accessibility should be at the forefront of discussion. Otherwise, are you really discussing for the purpose of spreading knowledge, or tooting your own horn?
|
Oh, I suppose some of my posts (OK, probably most of them) are a little longer than the average post in this forum, guilty as charged…
There is a reason behind this. I am a systems and network guy, but part of my job is also to teach my users and sometimes external attendees as well. Since 1995 I have accumulated something like 15,000 hours in adult education and training, from beginners to specialty workshops for experts. What I learned in doing this is that you can’t teach an adult by saying “do it because I tell you so”, you have to provide the reason behind it and if possible an example to explain something.
This has certainly rubbed of, I know that I sometimes try to explain something which might be obvious (at least for some/most readers), but that’s another thing, you can’t assume that everybody you explain something to has already a certain knowledge, you always start with some basics to lay the groundworks.
I don’t have the ambition to write any “academic paper” in this forum, but if I think it is necessary to make my point and to explain my reasoning I will do so, without adding a summery and a conclusion for the “lazy” reader. If you don’t want to read it all, but comment it anyway, I might call certain points to your attention I made in the previous post.
Accessibility is a nice thing to have, but as I said, in my opinion it is better to provide your reasoning in the first place and not handing it out in pieces one post at a time.
“Tooting my own horn” – never heard that before, learned something new here…

But seriously, don’t you think if I really wanted to toot my horn I would post more often than I do? I write something if I think I can add some helpful information, preferable first-hand experience I made myself. I don’t need to mix myself in any thread just to push my post count.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigsnakegirl785
The downfalls you listed are definitely important, but most can be worked around and aren't necessarily true 100% of the time. I do agree that a well-designed viv from the beginning is ideal, but isn't always realistic for the average reptile owner. You can still make those "suboptimal set ups" adequate with good planning, and when using them for appropriate species or during appropriate stages in their life.
So, I don't really agree with the "no tubs not ever" stance you seem to be putting off on what I have read. When I have more time, perhaps I'll read over more of the rest. Saying "just replace your tub with a better set up" is not an appropriate response, and is not helpful.
|
Why not? If I think a tub is not the optimal enclosure to provide the enrichment we could provide to any of our reptiles if we used an adequately sized enclosure with the right equipment, why should I not point it out? Especially if I provide the reasons why I think it to be suboptimal?
I suppose we can agree on not agreeing on the usability of tubs as longtime enclosures. I explained my reasons why I think tubs are suboptimal, if you don’t agree or only partly agree I suppose I can’t change your mind. I suppose you think the initial costs of buying a terrarium is more than the “average beginner” is willing to invest. On the other hand, a glass terrarium or a plywood terrarium 120 x 60 x 60 cm (4 x 2 x 2 ft) is about 150 Euro (ca 180 USD) if you buy it retail. If you consider the costs of all the other equipment, the snake, future costs for energy, food, probably vet etc this doesn’t seem an enormous amount for the initial investment if it lets you add so much more enrichment for your reptile…
So, I did it again, writing a wall of text, explaining my reasoning, providing examples, teaching (I hope you don’t think of it as preaching)