What's the issue? The inconsistent feeding or the lazy kill?

The inconsistent feedings could be due to the cooler temps or breeding season. If it's eating erratically just offer food less often. I wouldn't worry about the lazy kill either. Snakes will use the appropriate force needed to subdue their prey. Maybe it sensed that particular weaner would surrender peacefully. Do you raise your own feeders? If not, can I ask what are the conveniences of feeding live vs. f/t to you?
@ TRD- I'm not sure about the nutritional benefits of mice vs. rats but I'd like to see those studies. Also, I'm not sure how large the OPs critter is but I don't think a weaned rat every 10 days is too much food for a 2 y/o corn snake.