Quote:
Originally Posted by bigsnakegirl785
First news I've heard of real signs of breeding, good to know! As you said, even if they're established they don't really have the ability to survive in the rest of the US, except maybe Hawaii, if they got there?
I'll leave the ecological information up to the experts, as I'm not experienced in this area, but that thread seemed to be rather argumentative, in many cases unnecessarily so, while also talking in circles. It did seem to at least show there are baby Burms in the Florida wild if nothing else, but at least the first page and half the second page left much to be desired, being mostly name-slinging and accusatory with maybe half of it being informative. Perhaps I just need to sit down and dissect the thread a bit better.
I am curious to know, if in a hypothetical situation where Burms and other tropical invasive snakes could actually invade the rest of the US, if the Lacey Act would even be an effective measure to controlling or getting rid of them? It seems an established wild breeding population of an invasive species would not be much affected by stopping transportation into the state?
|
You have to look past the flaming, those guys all know each other very well and that's just the way they communicate. There are countless threads on that forum on a huge variety of subjects those guys discuss with just as much energy. There is a lot of information and many points of view offered in the thread, and there are many more threads on the same subjects elsewhere on the forum. Keep in mind that it is a field herping forum, many diehard field herpers do not necessarily approve of people keeping reptiles and may even support HSUS. The subject of herpetoculture is often hotly debated as well.
I don't think the Lacey act would have much effect in your hypothetical situation, particularity with animals like Burms and Retics that are no doubt already kept in just about every state of the continental U.S. Hawaii is a different story, there are no snakes native to Hawaii and it is illegal to bring any snakes in. Isolated ecosystems such as islands are very vulnerable to invasive species of just about any kind. A bit of research into what feral cats have done to countless island ecosystems around the globe is proof enough of that, not to mention the Brown Tree Snake disaster in Guam. Now in a case like Brown Tree Snakes, which are not popular in the pet trade, the Lacey Act is actually a viable form of control. Brown Tree Snakes have been on the Lacey Act for a long time now, though I haven't been able to find out exactly when they were added. They were the only reptile on the Lacey Act before the constrictors were added three years ago. I don't know if Brown Tree Snakes would be a real threat to establish in the continental U.S. or if they were just banned as a knee-jerk reaction to the Guam situation. But I do know the constrictors were not added because they could become established in North America outside of Florida, they were added because "animal rights" groups (most notably HSUS) threw a lot of money at it. So much money that the FWS overlooked legitimate research and based its decision to add the constrictors primarily on
this report, a report that has been widely discredited. There is hope still, USARKs lawsuit against the FWS has science on its side. The opposition only has millions of dollars donated by mislead bleeding hearts who thought their money was going to help the suffering puppys and kittens in the TV commercials. The law is blind to money, right?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jrich
Feral cats though....
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jrich
I feel like this is going to create a lot of unintended consequences.
|
Agreed, and agreed.