border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Python Forums > Giant Python Discussion

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-22-13, 11:36 PM   #61
EmbraceCalamity
Member
 
EmbraceCalamity's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2012
Age: 35
Posts: 1,431
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by iBaman View Post
So tell the burm that just destroyed the pet store's nice enclosure (10x6x9) that has a waterfall, plenty of hiding space and that jazz that she NEEDS a huge enclosure. Left her there a week, and she was stressed, didn't stop moving. Put her in a 6ft cage and what do you know...nice and calm.
Wow, wild burms must all be having panic attacks 24/7.

Also, again, no one said these snakes "NEED" huge enclosures. My entire last post was about that very point.

~Maggot
__________________
Announcing "I'm offended" is basically telling the world you can't control your own emotions, so everyone else should do it for you.
EmbraceCalamity is offline  
Old 01-22-13, 11:41 PM   #62
limey
Member
 
limey's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun-2012
Location: East Coast USA. Originally from England.
Posts: 321
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by EmbraceCalamity View Post
No one here said they're not "fine" in those size enclosures. People are arguing that it's not anywhere near ideal. The issue people take with it is that, despite the fact that they will survive, they won't thrive, as it is not a suitable size for such a large snake. People have decided to keep the enclosures small just because it's more convenient for them, not because it's what's best (not "fine" - best) for the snake.

Personally, I don't want something an animal will be "fine" in. My leopard gecko would be "fine" in a 10 gallon, but I keep her in a 20 long, which is almost double the floor space of what she would be "fine" in. My crocodile gecko would be "fine" in a 10 gallon, but I keep her in a 33 gallon. My kingsnake would be "fine" in a 20 high (for now), but I keep her in a 29 gallon (and will be upgrading her to something larger). I want the best for my reptiles; I want them to thrive, not be "fine." And that is where you and I differ.

~Maggot
Exactly. Big snake owners/breeders can keep their retic collection in their proportionately small enclosures and let them stay alive and in reasonable health, but it's far from ideal. It's what's best for the breeder/keeper not what's best for the animal, and that is what you might call unethical. A giant snake needs it's own room with free roaming space, not a 6 foot box.

PM Bronxzoofrank - he's been working with and studying giant snakes longer than some members have been alive.
__________________
Curator of Reptiles at a reputable zoo.
limey is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 03:43 AM   #63
Lankyrob
Non Carborundum Illegitimi
 
Lankyrob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2010
Location: Keynsham
Age: 51
Posts: 9,556
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
the method that was always used when I came up was the length of the snake halved by 3 deep and 2 high so a 16 foot snake should have an 8x3x2 most people when imahining a large retic imagine twinkie from PP wher as my 15 foot female is not even in the same league which means in her cage out of 24 sq feet of floor she would be lucky if she used 4 sq feet of it and the rules that everyone keeps mentioning where did the come from and how did they become reptile law if you dont mind me asking?
Thanks for the response. The rule when i got into snakes that i have been brought up with is that the snake needs a viv that if it lies along the length it cant then reach the front of the viv. So a 5ft snake would need something as a minimum that is 3x2ft.

As a newb i assumed that this "rule" applied to all snakes and then saw pictures of (using your own example) a 16ft snake in a viv that only allows 11ft to stretch out.

This was the basis for my initial query in this thread as i wondered at what size the "rule" tha i had been told went out the window and things change.
__________________
May you have more good days than bad
You never know how strong you are - until being strong is your only choice
There are no dark clouds - just well hidden silver linings!!
Lankyrob is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 05:05 AM   #64
tommy757
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 18
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by iBaman View Post
So tell the burm that just destroyed the pet store's nice enclosure (10x6x9) that has a waterfall, plenty of hiding space and that jazz that she NEEDS a huge enclosure. Left her there a week, and she was stressed, didn't stop moving. Put her in a 6ft cage and what do you know...nice and calm.
my genetic stripe is the same way
tommy757 is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 05:13 AM   #65
tommy757
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 18
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lankyrob View Post
Thanks for the response. The rule when i got into snakes that i have been brought up with is that the snake needs a viv that if it lies along the length it cant then reach the front of the viv. So a 5ft snake would need something as a minimum that is 3x2ft.

As a newb i assumed that this "rule" applied to all snakes and then saw pictures of (using your own example) a 16ft snake in a viv that only allows 11ft to stretch out.

This was the basis for my initial query in this thread as i wondered at what size the "rule" tha i had been told went out the window and things change.
well you gotta look at it this way if the cage is 8 feet long then the sanke can double back to reach the 16 feet if she did it in a straight line wich they never do theres always a few curves in there if not loops
tommy757 is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 01-23-13, 10:07 AM   #66
Lankyrob
Non Carborundum Illegitimi
 
Lankyrob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar-2010
Location: Keynsham
Age: 51
Posts: 9,556
Country:
Re: need a little help here

But sureely doubling back isnt stretching out? And you didnt answer the question about how big the snake needs to be before the "rule" ( bad use of the word i know) changes? Are you saying a six foot snake can go in a three foot enclosure cos it can double back on itself? Please dont think i am trying to be "arsey" about this, i am genuinely interested to know.
__________________
May you have more good days than bad
You never know how strong you are - until being strong is your only choice
There are no dark clouds - just well hidden silver linings!!
Lankyrob is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 10:18 AM   #67
Aaron_S
Forum Moderator
 
Aaron_S's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov-2002
Location: Toronto
Age: 41
Posts: 16,978
Send a message via MSN to Aaron_S
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
the thing our buddy above just said was that his balls do fine in a small enclosure and so do all of our retics and thats the point if it works and well,why change it.
Aaron why so aggressive you show youre inexperiance and ignorance by tryin to beat up on people who dont agree with you ,oh and by the way if any of the big name guys are right not just the private keepers then retics are just fine in 8/10 foot enclosures since bobs been doing it for 30 years right along with the baldagos and tom crutchfield hell man the list goes on and on its no longer opinion when every major player in the game does it the same way and buddy you are inexperianced with maybe 10 years ive got double that also with healthy snakes and a zero mortality rate Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm maybe im doin it right

it seems you justify the tiny tiny enclosure because you breed well congrats but the green eyed monster is starring at ya bud dont get Butt hurt

oh and in the 90,s you were still watchin barney youre first herp while I had real snakes.
Can you please start properly typing and making coherent sentences so I can understand your points easier. Thanks. My kiddie eyes don't read gibberish well.

First of, my argument is they shouldn't be owned in the first place. Nobody needs to own giants. Especially in tiny enclosures. As I said, if you breed, go ahead. All those people you mentioned breed for a living, I believe they are the exception to the rule. We're talking about the person who owns one or two.

It's funny how I'm "aggressive" and not just passionate in my opinion. Yet, the "informed" and "experienced" are the ones who take shots at my character and age. By the way, congratulations for being born before me I'll give you a cookie.

Also, apparently age means experience to you. I've said it multiple times that I've had experience and yet it's washed aside because I don't side with YOU. That's just sad. I'm open-minded to concede my points when given but I have yet to have a solid reason why they should be kept in general.
Aaron_S is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 10:26 AM   #68
Aaron_S
Forum Moderator
 
Aaron_S's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov-2002
Location: Toronto
Age: 41
Posts: 16,978
Send a message via MSN to Aaron_S
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by iBaman View Post
So tell the burm that just destroyed the pet store's nice enclosure (10x6x9) that has a waterfall, plenty of hiding space and that jazz that she NEEDS a huge enclosure. Left her there a week, and she was stressed, didn't stop moving. Put her in a 6ft cage and what do you know...nice and calm.
Wow..ONE snake (two I guess since Tommy says his genetic stripe is the same). That makes the entire case. I have a ball python that is really feisty so ALL of them in the entire WORLD are the same.

I'd be stressed out too with people gawking at me, probably tapping the glass, in a high traffic area with a waterfall making a lot of vibrations that I can't get away from. Not all animals make good display animals.

How big is/was the burm?

As you stated, people can't deal with large enclosures, so you cram them into really small ones because they do OKAY and so you can have your selfish need to own them. Nothing more about it. Selfish, selfish needs.

Yes, I know the reply you'll make. I keep ball pythons in tubs. Yes, I run a business. It's a different topic compared to the ONE burm or ONE retic.
Aaron_S is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 11:39 AM   #69
Pirarucu
Member
 
Pirarucu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2012
Posts: 2,054
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by iBaman View Post
So tell the burm that just destroyed the pet store's nice enclosure (10x6x9) that has a waterfall, plenty of hiding space and that jazz that she NEEDS a huge enclosure. Left her there a week, and she was stressed, didn't stop moving. Put her in a 6ft cage and what do you know...nice and calm.
So why is that definitely a sign of stress? Could that not be natural behavior that most keepers don't recognize as natural, as they aren't able to do so in small cages? In a small cage, they can't behave that way, so it must mean it's a bad thing? I'd be more interested in whether it was eating and drinking regularly... All you seem to have done is proved my earlier point, and said it must be stress, not natural behavior.
Pirarucu is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 12:17 PM   #70
Terranaut
Morelia Enjoyus Maximus
 
Terranaut's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Location: Kitchener
Age: 55
Posts: 4,615
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Was going to leave it alone but here we go.
Bigger is better for the snake. Smaller is better for the keeper.
In the middle somewhere lies a point where the snake will be happy never having been outside and the keeper will be happy it's not something huge. Now too much open space can be an issue. Sticking even this big beast into an empty gymnasium without ground cover and the snake will eventually end up in a corner trying to use 3 sides for cover. In the dark this same snake would lurk every inch of the edge of the gym looking for escape or cover. Now fill that gym with dirt and rocks with some trees and shrubbs and this guy will be in heaven. IMHO bigger has got to always be better if you supply appropriate cover and apparatus for the snake. Snakes stress over open spaces not big enclosures.
I heard a rumour once. They say snakes actually survive ...outside!! You know ... where it's measures in square miles not square inches.

I like the rule mentioned as a minimum but I try to keep my snakes in karge as possible enclosures. Even my royal has a 4x2x16"
__________________
0.1 BCI 1.1.2 Jungle Carpet Pythons 1.0 Jungle Jag 1.0 Goins King Snake 0.1 Leopard Gecko 0.1 Albino Gopher Snake 1.0 Pastel Ball Python
Terranaut is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 01-23-13, 07:45 PM   #71
tommy757
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 18
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by Terranaut View Post
Was going to leave it alone but here we go.
Bigger is better for the snake. Smaller is better for the keeper.
In the middle somewhere lies a point where the snake will be happy never having been outside and the keeper will be happy it's not something huge. Now too much open space can be an issue. Sticking even this big beast into an empty gymnasium without ground cover and the snake will eventually end up in a corner trying to use 3 sides for cover. In the dark this same snake would lurk every inch of the edge of the gym looking for escape or cover. Now fill that gym with dirt and rocks with some trees and shrubbs and this guy will be in heaven. IMHO bigger has got to always be better if you supply appropriate cover and apparatus for the snake. Snakes stress over open spaces not big enclosures.
I heard a rumour once. They say snakes actually survive ...outside!! You know ... where it's measures in square miles not square inches.



I like the rule mentioned as a minimum but I try to keep my snakes in karge as possible enclosures. Even my royal has a 4x2x16"
and all that sounds great when nature is recycling thier waste and washing everything down when it rains but in captivity that is near impossible and there is also the safty issue for the snake and the keeper .they are not a ball you can pic up and sit on a table to clean the cage its an apex predator that on instinct might strike causing injury to both keeper and snake.Im not just talking retics I dont know about you but I wouldnt wanna take a bite to the face from a 10 foot carpet a more with a more functional design aka known as dividers all the stress on both parties can be avoided does that make sense?
tommy757 is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 08:04 PM   #72
tommy757
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 18
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aaron_S View Post
Can you please start properly typing and making coherent sentences so I can understand your points easier. Thanks. My kiddie eyes don't read gibberish well.

First of, my argument is they shouldn't be owned in the first place. Nobody needs to own giants. Especially in tiny enclosures. As I said, if you breed, go ahead. All those people you mentioned breed for a living, I believe they are the exception to the rule. We're talking about the person who owns one or two.

It's funny how I'm "aggressive" and not just passionate in my opinion. Yet, the "informed" and "experienced" are the ones who take shots at my character and age. By the way, congratulations for being born before me I'll give you a cookie.

Also, apparently age means experience to you. I've said it multiple times that I've had experience and yet it's washed aside because I don't side with YOU. That's just sad. I'm open-minded to concede my points when given but I have yet to have a solid reason why they should be kept in general.
well as you said you a opposed to them being kept at all so it doesnt matter that a huge portion of us use the accepted method of housing?I feel no matter what is said or how its presented you sir are a keyboard warrior who can hide in safety from a legitamite discussion and balk at anyone that has a different view on the same hobbie you sir are the reason we as a hobbie are divided being determined to alienate those that dont agree w/ you...is that the proper response you were looking for?
One final point in youre own words if you profit from them than anything is acceptable so who here is morally bankrupt not I for keeping my animals in clean ,safe,enviroment feeding them only the best and diverse food sources.While they live in a blissful state free from parasites and predators and yes unlike you stuffed into a tub because you make money off thier suffering !Is this clear have a great day running youre puppy mill at least in principle.
tommy757 is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 08:20 PM   #73
tommy757
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2013
Posts: 18
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lankyrob View Post
But sureely doubling back isnt stretching out? And you didnt answer the question about how big the snake needs to be before the "rule" ( bad use of the word i know) changes? Are you saying a six foot snake can go in a three foot enclosure cos it can double back on itself? Please dont think i am trying to be "arsey" about this, i am genuinely interested to know.
Rob it has been proven that large snakes are ambush predators that will remain mostly still waitin for somthing to come by for extended periods the three to four times a week my "giants"are out is probably more excercise than they would get in nature in a month long stretch .BTWif you ever noticed that they start to breath loudly after extended movement it probably because they are building up lactic acid wich tires them out .They are panting they arent triathletes they are designed for short bursts of exertion.

It seems that alot of people here are concerned w/ length a six foot GTP would be absolutly good in a three foot enclosure as long as they had places to hang but I would not put a six foot long blood that weighs 30 pounds in a three by three its not just the length that needs to be considered its the width as well as thier natural behaviors so just to tie it in a 7 foot retic is about they width of a D batterie and will generally use considerably less space than a seven foot carpet than is double the width and partially arboreal.does this kinda help?
tommy757 is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 08:44 PM   #74
Pirarucu
Member
 
Pirarucu's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr-2012
Posts: 2,054
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
and all that sounds great when nature is recycling thier waste and washing everything down when it rains but in captivity that is near impossible and there is also the safty issue for the snake and the keeper .they are not a ball you can pic up and sit on a table to clean the cage its an apex predator that on instinct might strike causing injury to both keeper and snake.Im not just talking retics I dont know about you but I wouldnt wanna take a bite to the face from a 10 foot carpet a more with a more functional design aka known as dividers all the stress on both parties can be avoided does that make sense?
So what you're saying is it boils down to the keeper wanting to own a large snake, but not wanting to deal with the logistics and effort of housing and caring for one?
Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
well as you said you a opposed to them being kept at all so it doesnt matter that a huge portion of us use the accepted method of housing?I feel no matter what is said or how its presented you sir are a keyboard warrior who can hide in safety from a legitamite discussion and balk at anyone that has a different view on the same hobbie you sir are the reason we as a hobbie are divided being determined to alienate those that dont agree w/ you...is that the proper response you were looking for?
One final point in youre own words if you profit from them than anything is acceptable so who here is morally bankrupt not I for keeping my animals in clean ,safe,enviroment feeding them only the best and diverse food sources.While they live in a blissful state free from parasites and predators and yes unlike you stuffed into a tub because you make money off thier suffering !Is this clear have a great day running youre puppy mill at least in principle.
If you read his posts correctly, you would know that he is not opposed to keeping them, he feels like we all do. Don't keep an animal if you don't want to provide for it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
Rob it has been proven that large snakes are ambush predators that will remain mostly still waitin for somthing to come by for extended periods the three to four times a week my "giants"are out is probably more excercise than they would get in nature in a month long stretch .BTWif you ever noticed that they start to breath loudly after extended movement it probably because they are building up lactic acid wich tires them out .They are panting they arent triathletes they are designed for short bursts of exertion.

It seems that alot of people here are concerned w/ length a six foot GTP would be absolutly good in a three foot enclosure as long as they had places to hang but I would not put a six foot long blood that weighs 30 pounds in a three by three its not just the length that needs to be considered its the width as well as thier natural behaviors so just to tie it in a 7 foot retic is about they width of a D batterie and will generally use considerably less space than a seven foot carpet than is double the width and partially arboreal.does this kinda help?
Proven by who? Or is it just conventional thought that is repeated so often that it is accepted as true? How many people have gone and observed retics in the wild?
Also, I have never heard heavy breathing. There is new thought going around that most snakes in captivity are somewhat overweight and out of shape, due to diet and small caging. I'd guess that's the cause of your heavy breathing..
I have a retic and a carpet python, both around seven feet. Both climb, and the retic is considerably more active and intelligent...

Last edited by Pirarucu; 01-23-13 at 08:49 PM..
Pirarucu is offline  
Old 01-23-13, 08:54 PM   #75
EmbraceCalamity
Member
 
EmbraceCalamity's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2012
Age: 35
Posts: 1,431
Country:
Re: need a little help here

Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
Rob it has been proven that large snakes are ambush predators that will remain mostly still waitin for somthing to come by for extended periods the three to four times a week my "giants"are out is probably more excercise than they would get in nature in a month long stretch.
Do you have a source for this whole statement? I fail to believe that these snakes stay in one spot for 3-4 weeks in the wild. They very well might be ambush predators (though there is proof that they aren't always), but that doesn't mean they stay still. Please read up on the optimal foraging theory.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tommy757 View Post
BTWif you ever noticed that they start to breath loudly after extended movement it probably because they are building up lactic acid wich tires them out .They are panting they arent triathletes they are designed for short bursts of exertion.
Actually, Burmese pythons can climb trees (particularly when smaller) and are excellent swimmers. But any animal that never gets to move around more than once a month obviously is going to have trouble with it when they finally get to.

~Maggot
__________________
Announcing "I'm offended" is basically telling the world you can't control your own emotions, so everyone else should do it for you.
EmbraceCalamity is offline  
Login to remove ads
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right