border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Lizard Forums > Varanid

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-08-12, 05:37 PM   #166
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by crocdoc View Post
Even if that skink is now dead, it has lived for at least 50 years. I'd be really surprised if the potential lifespan for a savannah monitor, a much larger reptile which also takes longer to reach sexual maturity in the wild, would be only 10 years. It will probably not be anywhere near 50, but surely a lot longer than captives are currently living.

I want to see some data and proof. Can you provide a receipt from when your friend bought the skink, Sir? Can you provide the feeding records from the last 50 years, Sir? LMFAO...

I understand what you are saying Dave, but can we really formulate an average life span in the wild or in captivity? Thats what I was getting at. Has there actually been any (and I hate to use this word LOL) data compiled from keepers around the world?

I do not feel that there is much difference in the number of animals that live to their potential in captivity to those in the wild percentage wise. And in my opinion, there are too many variables in both situations to even get a round about number.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."

Last edited by Gregg M; 03-08-12 at 05:45 PM..
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 01:49 AM   #167
crocdoc
Member
 
crocdoc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2004
Location: Australia
Posts: 976
Send a message via AIM to crocdoc
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

It's a tricky one. Higher survival rate of hatchlings in captivity because there are no predators, but once they reach that size/age at which they'd be smooth sailing in the wild they start dropping off in captivity. I think more wild ones reach their potential than captives, in terms of longevity, especially when talking about savannah monitors and Niles.
crocdoc is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 02:21 AM   #168
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

It is my goal (weather I can reach it or not is another question) to keep the new one alive for so long that no one believes me when I tell them about it.

BTW - I was just watering my enclosure and I have a whole bunch of crickets running around in there, I have not purchased any crickets, the cricket eggs in the sod I harvested from my lawn have hatched!! there is a whole micro ecosystem in that cage, and it's flourishing!!

Of course, next week when I drop a baby monitor in there, that micro ecosystem is going to get eaten quickly.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 07:36 PM   #169
Freebody
Veteran Member
 
Freebody's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug-2008
Location: Surrey BC
Age: 44
Posts: 2,379
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

my 2 cents..... sure savs eat rodents in the wild, i agree savs are oportuntic feeders, mine will eat anything im sure, mine tries to eat the the sofa for crying out loud lol and sure conditions are harsh in africa so sure they would need to adapt, but heres the problem i see with this, 1 savs in the wild can afford to eat rodents, ie Trash food like are potatoe chips we all love, but <<<< the freaking are in the wild running god knows how much distance burning off all that **** food and avoiding the bad side effects, a body builders diet would kill a couch potatoe, but works out fine for the lifter, 2 is the same as i just said, they can afford to eat the tasty not so good for them junk, and 3, treat your sav as you would your child, i have seen miricale stories of infants survival horrific events, many people have suffered child abuse and all sorts, and survived and even lead a succesfull life, BUT!! Just because maybe you could treat it like **** and it could even survive just fine perhaps, Why the hell would you want your child/sav for say, to go through that??? so why would you not just try your best to give it as close to the natural living conditions as posible with out argument? sounds like kinda a crazy argument ? dont mean to sound rude, im really not trying to, just keep reading these 3 points over and over and it boggle my mind, im not by and sence of the word a pro keeper, as im sure when im old and grey i hope to be still learning about my passion as im sure we all, i love the sav threads here, but sifting through this to get the diamond in the rough is a little hard some times oh and whats the title of the book i should read, im interested in reading this book, and learn more about wild savs? thanks.

Last edited by Freebody; 03-09-12 at 07:41 PM..
Freebody is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 08:08 PM   #170
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Freebody View Post
my 2 cents..... sure savs eat rodents in the wild, i agree savs are oportuntic feeders, mine will eat anything im sure, mine tries to eat the the sofa for crying out loud lol and sure conditions are harsh in africa so sure they would need to adapt, but heres the problem i see with this, 1 savs in the wild can afford to eat rodents, ie Trash food like are potatoe chips we all love, but <<<< the freaking are in the wild running god knows how much distance burning off all that **** food and avoiding the bad side effects, a body builders diet would kill a couch potatoe, but works out fine for the lifter, 2 is the same as i just said, they can afford to eat the tasty not so good for them junk, and 3, treat your sav as you would your child, i have seen miricale stories of infants survival horrific events, many people have suffered child abuse and all sorts, and survived and even lead a succesfull life, BUT!! Just because maybe you could treat it like **** and it could even survive just fine perhaps, Why the hell would you want your child/sav for say, to go through that??? so why would you not just try your best to give it as close to the natural living conditions as posible with out argument? sounds like kinda a crazy argument ? dont mean to sound rude, im really not trying to, just keep reading these 3 points over and over and it boggle my mind, im not by and sence of the word a pro keeper, as im sure when im old and grey i hope to be still learning about my passion as im sure we all, i love the sav threads here, but sifting through this to get the diamond in the rough is a little hard some times oh and whats the title of the book i should read, im interested in reading this book, and learn more about wild savs? thanks.
We can do better than this....



__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-09-12, 08:31 PM   #171
Freebody
Veteran Member
 
Freebody's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug-2008
Location: Surrey BC
Age: 44
Posts: 2,379
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

sweet thanks wayne, thats the one i was looking at. looks like that sav pic is in the wild, wonder why its so skinny and gaunt looking, i bet it didnt make it more than a few weeks after that photo If i ever seen one looking like that in person and it wasnt at a rescue place or somthing, someone would not be walking away from that meeting, and im sure it would not me me.... really sad.
Freebody is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 09:24 PM   #172
bodiddleyitis
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Posts: 68
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Ha ha ha ha ha, I left that one for the crow to pluck

"sure savs eat rodents in the wild, i agree savs are oportuntic feeders"

Savannah monitors aren't opportunistic feeders in the wild. They are after very specific types of prey and none of them are rodents. I think that's because they couldn't compete with all the other animals that are feeding on rodents; if they come across small enough rodents of course they will eat them but the search patterns they use turn up a rather narrow range of invertebrates, snails, and frogs with the odd reptile egg and that's what is in their guts almost all of the time. Of course the range of the species is very wide and our sample sizes are very small, but so far its feeding ecology looks rather specialised compared to opportunistic monitor species.

I think that you can recognise, or define, opportunistic monitors in the wild, by seeing if they are attracted to rotten carrion. If you try to bait monitor lizards with carrion in Africa you will get niloticus but you will not get exanthematicus. If you did it in Malaysia you would get biawaks and bengalensis but you would not get rudicollis and you probably wouldn't get dumerilii either. If you did in the Philippines you would only get biawaks. It's a useful definition because it's a very easy test. I'd guess that if you did it in Indonesia you wouldn't get prasinus type animals and you have some surprise non shows amongst the others.

What do we know about the natural diets of these monitors that can't be attracted with bait? Of course their range is wide and our sample sizes are very small but they seem to have very tight dietary niches compared to their opportunistic counterparts. There's a conspicuous lack of what I would call snake food.

Incidentally; these non carrion eating monitor lizards tend to perform poorly in captivity, especially the ones that live in wet forests. In contrast the carrion eaters are generally considered quite easy to breed.

How such idle speculation can be applied to the feeding of monitor lizards in boxes is uncertain, because all monitor lizards that can be bred in boxes will apparently thrive for indefinite generations on a diet of rodents and invertebrates. There's (almost?) no documented evidence of generations of captive monitors raised without rodents, but for many years now people have been banging on about how vital it is to omit rodents from the diets of savannah monitor lizards in particular. Why could that be?

David H. Good 1998, REPTILE magazine. Misunderstanding the Savannah Monitor: An Argument for Changed Husbandry.

This junk article was based on a talk the author had heard, but apparently entirely failed to comprehend, about wild savannah monitors. The talk was at the only monitor lizard conference that has ever been held in the USA, in San Diego. David Good spectacularly got every single detail in his article wrong, and the only thing he remembered correctly was that no rodents had been found in the diet of savannah monitors. He used this to suggest a rethink of savannah monitor husbandry that should have landed him in prison. Ever since it's been regularly rehashed by generations of monitor keepers who have spectacularly failed to breed their lizards. "They need a natural diet in captivity", what utter nonsense.

What David Good should have done was listen to another talk on the same day by a man nobody in the monitor lizard world had ever heard of. I can honestly say that nobody I knew in that room believed a word of it at the time, but it sparked a complete revolution in the way monitor lizards were kept. More importantly, it introduced a completely different philosophy to the husbandry of captives; that captive conditions should improve on natural conditions rather than replicate them. In nature monitor lizards are constrained by limited heat, water, food and shelters. By removing these constraints he claimed monitor lizards would grow at phenomenal rates and become fecund beyond all expectations. When members of the audience objected to basking temperatures so high they could easily kill the lizards, he claimed that the monitors sought such heat out of their own free will.

"so why would you not just try your best to give it as close to the natural living conditions as posible with out argument? sounds like kinda a crazy argument ?" Not really, because natural conditions are harsh and it's just possible that savannah monitors actually prefer rodents to milipedes.

Anybody who has read to the end of this ramble deserves a nice picture
bodiddleyitis is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 10:26 PM   #173
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Im not sure I see the logic in your argument the same as you do Daniel. To me the idea that we can do better than nature seems like an old idea. I think a lot of the knowledge about reptiles, nutrition and varanids has grown in the last 15 years as well. And with those improved conditions, we are learning that some things are obviously good to change, like removing their natural predators and giving them enough energy on a regular basis. However, we have also learned that certain things need to stay close to their natural situation, like deep substrate, humidity and I truly believe one day, diet will be one of those. Not in the sense that its going to kill a monitor to have the odd rodent, but more in the sense of refocusing people on exactly what they are feeding their lizards. The more I read on this subject the more I am convinced; as we pay better attention to the feeder prey, the better it is for the lizard. And I just think that inverts are a more nutritious source of their energy. It may not be easier, it may not be simple, but then I think that is pretty descriptive of monitors in general
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 11:24 PM   #174
bodiddleyitis
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Posts: 68
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Fair comment Jarich. The problem is that you need to demonstrate that there is a diet that doesn't include rodents that can be used to maintain captive populations of monitor lizards through reproductive generations before you can safely say it shouldn't be done (I'm sure I've said this before). At the moment that evidence is entirely lacking, it's only internet rumours. That is the logic to my argument, otherwise I agree with you 100%.
bodiddleyitis is offline  
Old 03-09-12, 11:42 PM   #175
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis View Post
"so why would you not just try your best to give it as close to the natural living conditions as posible with out argument? sounds like kinda a crazy argument ?" Not really, because natural conditions are harsh and it's just possible that savannah monitors actually prefer rodents to milipedes.

Anybody who has read to the end of this ramble deserves a nice picture
Near the end when Chomper started refusing food I placed small live rats in his enclosure, he pursued, killed and ate those rats with gusto, even though he was sick, showing very clearly that he preferred them.

Rationalize it any way you want, he refused all the food items he used to readily take, he ignored live insects, yet the very moment the small weanling rats entered his enclosure, he hit them hard like a monitor should.

Everyone should read that to the end.

And thank you for the nice picture.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-10-12, 12:53 AM   #176
BarelyBreathing
Varanus Queen
 
BarelyBreathing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2012
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 5,078
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

There is a theory behind that, Wayne. The theory is that a sick monitor would choose the food item that a: is easiest to catch (which is taken out of the equation if you're tong feeding or offering dead prey), and/or b: offers the highest source of nutrients with the least amount of effort. (Now I'm not saying that rats offer better nutrients than bugs, I'm simply stating that one rat is more nutritious than one bug.)
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Whimsical Observer
A seed is a tiny plant, in a box, with its lunch.
BarelyBreathing is offline  
Old 03-10-12, 01:07 AM   #177
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by BarelyBreathing View Post
There is a theory behind that, Wayne. The theory is that a sick monitor would choose the food item that a: is easiest to catch (which is taken out of the equation if you're tong feeding or offering dead prey), and/or b: offers the highest source of nutrients with the least amount of effort. (Now I'm not saying that rats offer better nutrients than bugs, I'm simply stating that one rat is more nutritious than one bug.)
The live rat was not tong fed, he had to chase it down.

The bugs were offered at point blank range requiring no effort to take.

After seeing clear photographs of emaciated sickly wild lizards, I would find it cruel and inhumane to subject my captive animals to conditions that mimic their "natural" environment.

I am not saying it would be healthy to stuff an exanthematicus full of mice on a daily basis, but the reality of it is that given a healthy environment I don't perceive an occasional rodent as a lethal prey item either.

This entire journey has been an educational experience and will remain so as long as I keep an open mind. I simply cannot sit by stubbornly and not evaluate and reevaluate what is being said here.

My copy of the book has been ordered and when I recieve it I will read it cover to cover, twice if I have to, and I will take to heart what I read.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Old 03-10-12, 01:09 AM   #178
BarelyBreathing
Varanus Queen
 
BarelyBreathing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2012
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 5,078
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Nobody has ever said that the occasional mouse is lethal. The argument at hand is whether or not they are beneficial. They're the savannah monitor equivilent to feeding a child a Big Mac.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Whimsical Observer
A seed is a tiny plant, in a box, with its lunch.
BarelyBreathing is offline  
Old 03-10-12, 09:07 AM   #179
KORBIN5895
Village Idiot
 
KORBIN5895's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Age: 41
Posts: 7,360
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by infernalis View Post
I am not saying it would be healthy to stuff an exanthematicus full of mice on a daily basis, but the reality of it is that given a healthy environment I don't perceive an occasional rodent as a lethal prey item either.
I think you brought this conversation to the whole crux of the debate. Housing and
Moderation.

I am ignorant and have no personal experience with monitors. I don't have data, success or proof on what I am about to say.Hahaha! Sir.

In all honesty from what I have read here and elsewhere it seems 99% percent of all sav keepers (I don't know about other species) are ignorant and need hard and fast rules. This is proven by them doggedly saying the pet store knows best. They pack them into small aquariums with screen tops and say " the Savannah is dry. Why does it need more humidity?" They can't get past the fact that they fell for a lie so they hold onto to make it true. I have creeped other places looking at some truly scary sav enclosures.

As for the moderation part, moderation isn't the word I am looking for so someone please feel free to supply it or correct me.

It took Wayne almost five years and a tragic loss to come to the conclusion that it is okay to feed the occasional rodent. How long does it take people to realize an all rodent diet is killing their pet? Or better yet how many savs does it take to realize that. I was at my local pet store last night and a customer bought their third sac in two and a half years. The first two died in less than a year. People don't seem able to moderate what they do. It is one extreme or the other.
__________________
I used to be a nice guy but that don't get you anywhere. So now I'm just a piece of ****, idiot,
who's too stupid to care.

Last edited by infernalis; 03-10-12 at 11:12 AM..
KORBIN5895 is offline  
Old 03-10-12, 09:14 AM   #180
mo9e64
Member
 
Join Date: Nov-2010
Posts: 290
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

-I see rodents as being like a balanced meal with an occassional Big Mac.You have a kid who sits infront of a TV
mo9e64 is offline  
Login to remove ads
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:52 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right