border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Lizard Forums > Varanid

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-05-12, 01:03 PM   #61
BarelyBreathing
Varanus Queen
 
BarelyBreathing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2012
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 5,078
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

He claims that in one study of two hundred specimens, only one specimen was found to take a rodent. Keep in mind, that this was the only time that any rodents were ever found in the diet, and this definitely wasn't the only study done.

Our job as keepers (of any species, not ust savannah monitors) is to get as close as possible to their natural environment. This means providing the correct temperatures, humidity levels, substrate type, and diet. No one part of this is more important than any other part.

And yes, I have experience feeding snakes, as well as frogs and lizards, to monitors.

And while African snails are illegal here, I do breed other snails to suubstitute.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Whimsical Observer
A seed is a tiny plant, in a box, with its lunch.
BarelyBreathing is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 01:26 PM   #62
crocdoc
Member
 
crocdoc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2004
Location: Australia
Posts: 976
Send a message via AIM to crocdoc
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by mo9e64 View Post
By the way CrocDoc-Lizardheadmikes comments were the first i've seen where discussions from other forums crossed to Varanus.net.The hypocricy is so great here-this kind of commordery is practiced here everyday.Infact a group of you came to Reptile Canada to trash me which you denied,a lie-which i ignored thinking maybe at one point people would end this childish behaviour
Moe - I wasn't criticising him for coming from varanus.net to defend FR, I was merely explaining his motives to show that the basis was 'personal', despite him saying explicitly 'this is not personal'.

When you were attacked on Reptile Canada it was because you couldn't understand why everyone didn't want to immediately accept your regurgitation of FR's rants, despite you having very little personal experience with monitors. However, no one told me to go over there to attack you - I just saw your tanty to FR about it. You have the same problem that lizardheadmike has - you're a nice guy, but your admiration for FR stops you from being able to see anything clearly. If you pulled your head out for a minute and took a breath of fresh air, perhaps you'd understand why everyone is so tired of his ____. It's old, really old.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mo9e64 View Post
you know when things go to far when things like i should punch in you the head are takin' literally-depending where you come from there are different ways of saying this i say 'i feel like smackin you'-don't educated people like scientist know how to take things in context.I'll agree considering the discussion a better choice of words would have been better.
Moe, no one took him literally but no one has to to recognise that as an incredibly inappropriate thing to say on an internet forum. Especially in the context. He was called out on a deliberate distortion of truth and his only response (rather than an apology) was "I should punch you in the head". REALLY?

Seriously, Moe, pull your head out of there and get some sun on your face, it isn't good for your health. We know you admire him, but we're not going to see him in the same glowing light you do.

Last edited by crocdoc; 03-05-12 at 01:31 PM..
crocdoc is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 01:36 PM   #63
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gregg M View Post
To be fair here, everything we offer these animals in captivity is outside of their range of nature. Everything from food to soil types. You can come close to their natural environment but never replicate it perfectly.

Daniel also states that they do not eat rodents often. He never said they were void in their diet completely.

The insects we offer in captivity are a substitute for their actual diet in the wild. We can only offer what we have available to us. We have brown farm raised cricket and a few species of roach that are NOT native to Africa. If you really want to replicate their natural diet, I suggest you start breeding some African scorpions and snails to use as feeders.

Lets not forget the fact that savs do indeed take rodent and reptilian prey in the wild as well. Ever feed a live snake to a savannah? I have and I can tell you they know exactly what to do when it comes to killing it quickly and eating it. If you have ever seen one kill and eat a live rodent and a live snake, you would see that the killing methods are quite different. This tells me that they are evolved, opportunistic feeders. The fact is, where they come from, insects and molusks are very abundant hence the reason why they make up a lot of their natural diet.
Where they come from, rodents are very abundant as well Greg, so Im not sure that logic really works. I was present when someone fed a live mouse to a sav. It was actually the first thing that lead me to question them eating rodents as part of their diet. It didnt seem to me that it was very good at killing it, compared to larger monitors or other reptiles. The fact that they will take it doesnt mean much either. They will eat anything you give them, including dog or cat food. I think there is a guy online with videos of them eating scrambled eggs. Doesnt mean that they should be fed those items or that it is the healthiest item to feed them either. Just like their captive environment, we should always try our best to go further towards their best needs. Just because we cant exactly replicate it doesnt mean we give up on trying.

As to the comment about replicating their natural diet, here is a thought. We see that savannahs are specialized to a type of prey, but unspecialized within that type of prey group. Here is what I mean. They are specialized invert eaters, however the variety of inverts is not specialized. Often individual savs, with no vertebrates in their stomachs have over 30 different types of inverts in them. To me that says feed them inverts, and keep the variety up!

Again, Ill make the comparison Ive made many times. I think rodents are a little like bacon. Bacon isnt bad for you in and of itself, but if youre fat its not helping, and I doubt you will ever hear your doctor say, "hey you should eat more bacon"
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 02:10 PM   #64
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by BarelyBreathing View Post
He claims that in one study of two hundred specimens, only one specimen was found to take a rodent. Keep in mind, that this was the only time that any rodents were ever found in the diet, and this definitely wasn't the only study done..
All I really want to point out with this, is that study was conducted on Juvenile monitors, babies..

I'm just trying to approach all of this with logic and reasoning.

So if a baby were to stumble upon a nest of pinkie rodents in the wild, chances are the mother rodent would defend said nest with her life, therefore the small Savs would not be "unopposed" in it's attempt to eat the only size rodent it could fit in it's mouth.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"

Last edited by infernalis; 03-21-13 at 07:41 AM..
infernalis is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 02:26 PM   #65
BarelyBreathing
Varanus Queen
 
BarelyBreathing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2012
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 5,078
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by infernalis View Post
All I really want to point out with this, is that study was conducted on Juvenile monitors, babies..

I'm just trying to approach all of this with logic and reasoning.

So if a baby were to stumble upon a nest of pinkie rodents in the wild, chancer are the mother rodent would defend said nest with her life, therefore the small Savs would not be "unopposed" in it's attempt to eat the only size rodent it could fit in it's mouth.
Yes, correct, but again, this wasn't the only study done, and other studies have been focused on a larger age range.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Whimsical Observer
A seed is a tiny plant, in a box, with its lunch.
BarelyBreathing is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-05-12, 05:33 PM   #66
bodiddleyitis
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Posts: 68
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

I think maybe you just don't understand the way I write. It was in response to a question "How should you approach handling? Wait for it to come to you or can that only be achieved through daily handling when it doesn't seem too keen on it" well of course they are not keen on it and of course you would have to force them. If you think that's me encouraging people to force lizards into being handled you obviously have a problem with my language, I don't think many other people would interpret it like that. He didn't ask "should I handle my lizard" he asked "will it come to me for handling or will I have to force it?"

I said that savannah monitor lizards do not SHARE burrows with rodents (as far as I am aware). You said they do, and now you say that the reference to this is in the paper(s) that you have seen but can't remember where they are and don't recall the names of the authors exactly.

If you spent any time at all looking at the diets of wild monitor lizards you would see that they are often not optimal. I know of populations of biawaks that live largely on toads or ranid frogs; they are skinny and small and full of parasites. There are other populations that feed on turtle eggs, and some that live on human corpses and excrement, roadkill, dead fruit bats in caves. Those are "natural diets" but nobody in their right mind would recommend them as food for captives. The only way you could possibly feed imported savannah monitors a "natural" diet would be to ship in wild freshly caught prey items from Ghana every week, sprinkled liberally with local soil. You couldn't breed those prey species in the US because the captive raised ones would have a very different chemical composition to the ones in the wild for obvious reasons. Or at least the reasons should be obvious, but I have a feeling it won't be.

I'm not aware of people finding 30+ species of inverts in a single stomach, unless that is from Cisse's work in Senegal. I'm not aware of other field studies of exanthematicus except his and mine, I'm really hoping there are others out there but I find it strange that nobody can actually produce a citation. If you do a field work and you don't find stuff it doesn't mean it doesn't occur, only that you haven't found it. It's not an absolute science but it requires more field work to prove or disprove general theories about diet, not speculation. For this reason I'm getting rather tired of having this argument. You seem incapable of understanding what I write, which might be my fault. I think at this stage you need to produce these mystery papers and details of how the reptile place you work in has raised exanthematicus to F2/F3 on a diet of invertebrates alone. This is revolutionary stuff and if it's true it will show that savannah monitor lizards can be kept indefinitely on such a diet. It won't mean it's the only diet that's suitable for them, but it will mean that the diet you espouse has been proved to work. If anybody else knows of a similar situation let's hear from you. I'm keeping an open mind and waiting for you to produce something substantial to back up your case. Let's see the papers and details of this sensational breeding achievement, then your position will make much more sense. Until the papers and details of this f2/F3 breeding are available I don't think there is much point in continuing this conversation, but I'm looking forward to its resumption.
bodiddleyitis is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 05:47 PM   #67
KORBIN5895
Village Idiot
 
KORBIN5895's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Age: 41
Posts: 7,360
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Daniel could you please point me to where someone has claimed to raise three generations on an invertebrate diet I missed it and can't find it. Is calling you Daniel OK?
__________________
I used to be a nice guy but that don't get you anywhere. So now I'm just a piece of ****, idiot,
who's too stupid to care.
KORBIN5895 is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 05:57 PM   #68
jarich
Member
 
jarich's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct-2011
Posts: 2,237
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Oh come on, this is supposed to be my nice forum. I feel like some ole lady now telling everyone to chill all the time. I do really hope this can remain an open and forward debate and not a harsh back and forth.

In reference to the thing I said earlier about the 30 inverts in one specimen; the reference is one Im sure you know, Losos and Greene (1988). I know some of their collection sources are questionable, but he states there were numerous exanthematicus with a very high number of inverts like that.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
jarich is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 06:02 PM   #69
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

I have to take the standpoint that was brought up on another forum, Most of the Savannah monitors sold in pet stores wind up in the possession of very young people who are beguiled into believing they have an easy to care for animal that will do "just fine" in a large aquarium with a screen top and basking lamp.

Maybe I am strange, as I am 47 years old and enamoured by this "beginner's lizard", maybe Chomper stole my heart, who knows.

Back on topic, these young people need to learn to provide suitable environmental parameters, AKA build a decent cage and fill it with a suitable substrate to keep their animals alive and healthy.

So at this point in my never ending learning process, I feel the best advice we can give these younger keepers as far as diet is concerned it to make sure rubbish like dog food, scrambled eggs, cat food, wild caught frogs, etc.. are absolutely not offered.

By stating "I feed frogs" it is all but encouraging people to go forth and scoop up frogs off the ground as free food items. After all how many of these people have access to captive bred frogs? and since it is well known that frogs are a primary host to the flatworm parasite, this is just really bad to even suggest.

At least a bag of frozen mice from a reputable company like rodent pro will be chemical free and parasite free. Therefore much safer than kids grabbing frogs off the ground.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 06:57 PM   #70
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Where they come from, rodents are very abundant as well Greg, so Im not sure that logic really works.
At the risk of sounding a little bit like a jerk LOL, When was the last time you were in Afirca, more particularly where savannahs live? How do you know how abundant the rodent population is? Also keep in mind that most rodents are nocturnal from that part of the world and the varanids are diurnal. They paths may not cross often if there is in fact an abundance of rodents that share the same habitat.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
I was present when someone fed a live mouse to a sav. It was actually the first thing that lead me to question them eating rodents as part of their diet. It didnt seem to me that it was very good at killing it, compared to larger monitors or other reptiles.
You and I have had very different observations then. I have seen it hundreds of times. When I first started keeping monitors, there were no big frozen rodent companies. I will not say that your observation is wrong, just different.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
The fact that they will take it doesnt mean much either.
Actually it does mean a lot. The fact that they will eat rodents without hesitation, even fresh wild caughts, means that they must come into contact with, and feed on rodents.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
They will eat anything you give them, including dog or cat food. I think there is a guy online with videos of them eating scrambled eggs. Doesnt mean that they should be fed those items or that it is the healthiest item to feed them either. Just like their captive environment, we should always try our best to go further towards their best needs. Just because we cant exactly replicate it doesnt mean we give up on trying.
Yes, they will eat anything in captivity. Again this just further proves they are opportunistic as well as specialized. The odd scrambled egg every once in a while would be fine. They will eat eggs if they come across them in the wild. Obviously not cookrd though. LOL

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
As to the comment about replicating their natural diet, here is a thought. We see that savannahs are specialized to a type of prey, but unspecialized within that type of prey group. Here is what I mean. They are specialized invert eaters, however the variety of inverts is not specialized. Often individual savs, with no vertebrates in their stomachs have over 30 different types of inverts in them. To me that says feed them inverts, and keep the variety up!
I agree. However, those different inverts have very different nutritional values. These inverts are also eating plants and animals that are indigenous to the environment. Their gut loads are different from farmed raised brown crickets and such that we offer here. So again, we fall short of providing them with a "natural" diet. I am a huge advocate of a varied diet and it seems you are as well. Crickets, and a couple of different species of roach make up a huge part of our varanids diets. However, we also offer rodents as well. In my opinion, a 40% rodent based 60% is a very good ratio.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jarich View Post
Again, Ill make the comparison Ive made many times. I think rodents are a little like bacon. Bacon isnt bad for you in and of itself, but if youre fat its not helping, and I doubt you will ever hear your doctor say, "hey you should eat more bacon"
That is a very poor comparison. Rodents are a whole food item, not a fatty strip of flesh from a certain part of a pig.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis View Post
IIf you spent any time at all looking at the diets of wild monitor lizards you would see that they are often not optimal. I know of populations of biawaks that live largely on toads or ranid frogs; they are skinny and small and full of parasites. There are other populations that feed on turtle eggs, and some that live on human corpses and excrement, roadkill, dead fruit bats in caves. .
Daniel, do not forget about the numerous populations of Varanus salvator that live in and around garbage dumps.
__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."

Last edited by Gregg M; 03-05-12 at 07:02 PM..
Gregg M is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 03-05-12, 07:03 PM   #71
BarelyBreathing
Varanus Queen
 
BarelyBreathing's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2012
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 5,078
Country:
You seem incapable of sticking to your story. Seriously. Now are you saying to force handle them or not? People who keep monitors know that force handling is NOT the way of going about it, and instead you should use food to your advantage. Clearly, you aren't familiar with the behaviors of captive animals.

There was a conversation between you and Andrew Bentley on another forum, and now you're saying you aren't familiar with his work? Perhaps he was using a display name, much as you go by BoDiddleyitis, I go by BarelyBreathing, and so on and so forth.

So what you're saying to me is that because we cannot produce the exact diet that the animal eats in the wild, we should give up trying and feed them junk food? I'm sorry, but that makes little sense.

Korbin, it was I who stated that. For more information, just ask.

Savannah monitors will also readily eat items such as pencils, paper clips, and shoe laces, as was noted on several forums. Clearly, they must come across these things in the wild, and must eat them semi regularly, because they sure knew how to eat them in captivity.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Whimsical Observer
A seed is a tiny plant, in a box, with its lunch.

Last edited by infernalis; 03-05-12 at 07:11 PM..
BarelyBreathing is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 07:10 PM   #72
bodiddleyitis
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Posts: 68
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by KORBIN5895 View Post
Daniel could you please point me to where someone has claimed to raise three generations on an invertebrate diet I missed it and can't find it. Is calling you Daniel OK?
You can call me anything, I am getting used to it! Barelybreathing said this, on a different forum, but maybe it was two generations not three, either way it is new and exciting if it can be verified. I gather it's bad form to link from one forum to another but it shouldn't be hard to find.
bodiddleyitis is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 07:11 PM   #73
Gregg M
Squamata Concepts
 
Gregg M's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan-2003
Location: USA
Age: 51
Posts: 2,055
Send a message via Yahoo to Gregg M
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by BarelyBreathing View Post

So what you're saying to me is that because we cannot produce the exact diet that the animal eats in the wild, we should give up trying and feed them junk food? I'm sorry, but that makes little sense.
I do not recall anyone saying that. Rodents are not junk food and are a natural part of most varanid diets.

There are some aussie species that specialize in lizards like V. tristis. How many keepers do you think offer lizards as prey at all, much less as a staple.

This is captivity and there is only so much that can be replicated.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BarelyBreathing View Post
Savannah monitors will also readily eat items such as pencils, paper clips, and shoe laces, as was noted on several forums. Clearly, they must come across these things in the wild, and must eat them semi regularly, because they sure knew how to eat them in captivity.
Sorry, this is a bit silly and has nothing to do with the subject. You have to agree.

I found this sitting outside of a savannah monitor burrow.

__________________
"A sure fire way for a government to lose control of something is for them to prohibit it."

Last edited by Gregg M; 03-05-12 at 07:20 PM..
Gregg M is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 07:12 PM   #74
infernalis
Moderator
 
infernalis's Avatar
 
Join Date: May-2008
Location: Central New York State
Age: 62
Posts: 16,536
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodiddleyitis View Post
You can call me anything, I am getting used to it! Barelybreathing said this, on a different forum, but maybe it was two generations not three, either way it is new and exciting if it can be verified. I gather it's bad form to link from one forum to another but it shouldn't be hard to find.

You may link anything you like, if it supplements the conversation.
__________________
"Where would we be without the agitators of the world attaching the electrodes
of knowledge to the nipples of ignorance?"
infernalis is offline  
Old 03-05-12, 07:17 PM   #75
bodiddleyitis
 
Join Date: Mar-2012
Posts: 68
Country:
Re: It may be time to rethink a little (Savs)

Quote:
Originally Posted by infernalis View Post
I have to take the standpoint that was brought up on another forum, Most of the Savannah monitors sold in pet stores wind up in the possession of very young people who are beguiled into believing they have an easy to care for animal that will do "just fine" in a large aquarium with a screen top and basking lamp.

Maybe I am strange, as I am 47 years old and enamoured by this "beginner's lizard", maybe Chomper stole my heart, who knows.

Back on topic, these young people need to learn to provide suitable environmental parameters, AKA build a decent cage and fill it with a suitable substrate to keep their animals alive and healthy.

So at this point in my never ending learning process, I feel the best advice we can give these younger keepers as far as diet is concerned it to make sure rubbish like dog food, scrambled eggs, cat food, wild caught frogs, etc.. are absolutely not offered.

By stating "I feed frogs" it is all but encouraging people to go forth and scoop up frogs off the ground as free food items. After all how many of these people have access to captive bred frogs? and since it is well known that frogs are a primary host to the flatworm parasite, this is just really bad to even suggest.

At least a bag of frozen mice from a reputable company like rodent pro will be chemical free and parasite free. Therefore much safer than kids grabbing frogs off the ground.
This is exactly the problem. If you say feed them inverts, most will get a diet of mealworms. If you say feed them frogs or snails they will get wild snails and frogs and die as a result. We knew they could be bred on the diet we recommended and that's why we recommended it.
bodiddleyitis is offline  
Login to remove ads
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:52 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right