Quote:
Originally Posted by dannybgoode
So essentially you're advising people it's fine to deny a snake the ability to perform one of its fundamental behaviours with no scientific understanding of the importance of that behaviour and with no research or data to back up or prove what this magic temperature is or even be able tell me what it is?
You have no proof either that different species are all ok at the same temperature (and I can categorically say this is not the case).
But hey some snakes haven't died yet and some have even bred so it must be ok. The default position of people who follow breeder methodology (and I am not making just on here but in the hobby in general) is to demand papers from those advocating an alternate position.
As I say I have 6 or so papers on the subject, one of which does indeed compare snakes being allowed thermoregulate against those kept at a single temperature.
I am simply asking for the same. What scientific proof do you have that your method is not harmful - what proof do you have that denying a fundamental behaviour is ok?
|
First off, I'm not advising anyone to do anything. If something is working for them then why would they change it?
I also don't like the implication that I don't understand that some snakes bask in the wild or why they do it.
I've said that the temperature is in the 80 degrees F +/- a degree or two.
Some snakes? There are probably upwards of tens of thousands of snakes being kept in this manner with no ill effects. So many snakes have been kept this way and many different species.
You say you have 6 papers on the subject, you haven't posted any of them. This is you saying "I have a source and its a better source than yours just because I said so." There aren't many papers on the subject because very few people in the scientific community care about captive husbandry. Who would I go to in order to gain funding for such a long term and potentially costly study? Reptile care product companies wouldn't fund such a study at the risk of losing customers for their heating products and the scientific community probably just doesn't care. I only have my experiences with this method and the evidence that others have produced who do something similar.
I won't be encouraged to do something that adds an unnecessary variable to my enclosures that isn't offering any measurable benefit but has the risk to cause issues. If my snakes were listless or experiencing any kind of issues I would change it immediately but that's just flat out not the case. This method works as well as any other method does when done correctly for the same reason those methods work.
In regards to taking away their behaviors, I don't feel as if I'm stopping my snake from exploring it's enclosure, the many tunnels through the substrate prove that they remain as active as ever.
Anyways I've given my reasoning behind why I do what I do already, have a good evening.