border
sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum
 

Go Back   sSNAKESs : Reptile Forum > Community Forums > General Discussion

Notices

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 08-04-17, 07:25 AM   #106
Andy_G
Forum Moderator
 
Join Date: Dec-2002
Location: London
Posts: 3,332
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

What about the idea of incubation temps being the "ideal" for a species? Would this make sense to anyone else? Just a thought that I figured I would randomly throw that thought into the hat.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Louv44 View Post
Guy said he spoke to a well respected snake breeder who said snakes don't need a hotspot? My point was simply that totally stupid, cold blooded animals need heat!! That's not really a debate topic lol ok the analogy I used wasn't the best but I was so blown away i could of went on for days. If your going to get an animal any animal get everything it needs or just simply don't get it.

I'm sure the guys whole argument was they eat and breed so they are fine that's where the heroin analogy came in some people do it an live don't mean everyone who does it will live or that it's a good idea, he is lucky his snakes lived or didn't get sick at the very least.
Lou...have you read the entire thread, including all of the evidence that this may not necessarily be a bad idea? Up until your post it's for the most part been very intriguing and thought provoking. From your comments, I am assuming that you most likely haven't...for example you mention lack of heat, but that isn't even remotely what is being presented here, nor is anyone outrightly saying or arguing that it's indeed correct. I'd suggest actually reading and processing the information and conversation presented here by the insightful and intelligent members we have before dismissing it and regarding it as stupid. I can tell you, flat out, there are multiple species (asian rats, some central american milks, geckos of new caledonia) that thrive at room temp, don't really need to thermoregulate (or when given the opportunity to do so they just don't do it), and some species can actually be harmed or perish when kept at warmer temps or given a hot spot that's too hot...so although I get where you're coming from...it's not entirely correct either and your statement really adds nothing but insult to the discussion.
Andy_G is offline  
Old 08-04-17, 07:34 PM   #107
Louv44
Member
 
Join Date: Jul-2017
Posts: 28
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Scubadiver - first I certainly wasn't calling anyone stupid I would never do that and if I came off that way I apologize to everyone and I certainly don't consider myself a top 10,000 expert on the subject. I was calling that specific idea stupid. I don't think you need a lot of experience to know that in the wild cold blooded animals use heat to thermo-regulate and wouldn't it be fair to say we should provide any animal with what it would have in the wild? To answer your question I started keeping snakes when I was 11 but was around them before that cause my older brothers always had a bunch. I bred carpet pythons from 1994 to 2001, then wasout of the hobby until my kids wanted some 5 years ago. I've owned rat snakes, Corns, Kings, Ball pythons ( of course ) Argentine Boas, Columbian boas, Dominican red mountains but my main animal like I said was carpets. Again all we need to know that cold blooded animals need to thermo-regulate is any introductory science book? That's not debatable they are in fact cold blooded. So the win of not allowing them to do that is what? I saved a little money on a heat mat and thermostat and I can tell people look they lived! I just feel it's our duty if we choose to keep any animal we provide them with what they need they are helpless it's the correct thing to do. Again I agree I could written a much better post and again I apologize that's something I need to work on. It's just one mans opinion that it's wrong and really don't make sense, like why do that? What's the victory?
Louv44 is offline  
Old 08-04-17, 07:48 PM   #108
Louv44
Member
 
Join Date: Jul-2017
Posts: 28
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

AndyG - your 100 percent right I did not read the whole threat and should of before posting, can't argue a good point like that. I just apologized for some mistakes I made in a post to scubadiver as well.
Louv44 is offline  
Old 08-04-17, 11:04 PM   #109
Louv44
Member
 
Join Date: Jul-2017
Posts: 28
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Last thing I wanted to add why I didn't agree. Also in general I was just talking about day to day living for a cold blooded animal. Take the health thing out of the picture. All of us who keep snakes see 95 percent of our snakes throughout the day or week, sometimes on the hot side sometimes on the cooler side. Being cold blooded they feel that few degree difference. Keeping the tank one temp we are removing the ability for that animal to cool off if it chooses. I would think we all got into this hobby cause we care about reptiles so we should provide them with the best environment we can, if an individual doesn't care about reptiles for any reason that's totally ok but don't get any ever.

I think the biggest thing is why do it? What is the victory in it?

Anyway those are the reasons I didn't agree and just my opinion. No big deal not the end of the world. Scuba and Andy were right my posts were not done correctly and I should of read it all. That's on me, I apologized for that part of it.

I almost didn't even reply the real reason I joined is when my kids wanted snakes it reminded me of How much I enjoyed this hobby and love these animals. Wanted to join this community and talk with people who feel the same and help people if possible and also get help and learn, we can all always learn more. Anyway have a good weekend all!
Louv44 is offline  
Old 08-05-17, 12:45 AM   #110
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scubadiver59 View Post
Quite a few acerbic comments in there.

And what is your experience...how many years have you been keeping reptiles? How many snakes do you have...how many different species? How can you call someone "stupid" when you don't back up your statements with nothing other than that strange analogy about heroin and a doctor? You've heard the phrase, "comparing apples to oranges?" I don't see where an opoid abusing medical professional has anything to do with herpeculturists and reptile husbandry.
Doctor House was a pretty good doctor despite being on pills all the time lol.
jjhill001 is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 08-05-17, 01:10 AM   #111
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by Louv44 View Post
Last thing I wanted to add why I didn't agree. Also in general I was just talking about day to day living for a cold blooded animal. Take the health thing out of the picture. All of us who keep snakes see 95 percent of our snakes throughout the day or week, sometimes on the hot side sometimes on the cooler side. Being cold blooded they feel that few degree difference. Keeping the tank one temp we are removing the ability for that animal to cool off if it chooses. I would think we all got into this hobby cause we care about reptiles so we should provide them with the best environment we can, if an individual doesn't care about reptiles for any reason that's totally ok but don't get any ever.

I think the biggest thing is why do it? What is the victory in it?

Anyway those are the reasons I didn't agree and just my opinion. No big deal not the end of the world. Scuba and Andy were right my posts were not done correctly and I should of read it all. That's on me, I apologized for that part of it.

I almost didn't even reply the real reason I joined is when my kids wanted snakes it reminded me of How much I enjoyed this hobby and love these animals. Wanted to join this community and talk with people who feel the same and help people if possible and also get help and learn, we can all always learn more. Anyway have a good weekend all!
It's not ridiculous to have that first knee jerk reaction so I don't think anyone will blame you for it. I had the same reaction when I heard of it. The problem is when at least with the keeper I was speaking to who also manages the reptile collection in a well respected zoo, he's kept just about any species you could possibly keep. All at that same temp. He was a pioneer in Chondros (green tree pythons), Carpets and keeping those the same way he was keeping his Prairie Rattlesnakes that are from North Dakota.

If your interested at all in reptiles in general the entire thread has great information people on all sides of the debate and examples involving wild reptiles that aren't entirely reliant on the temperatures we may have once thought.

I'm gonna break down your questions point by point but please do read through the thread because I'm not just gonna rehash things I've already said:

-Why keep a tank at one temp: Well it's very difficult to keep a tank at one consistent temp throughout the day, if you go balls to the wall with the strategy you have to essentially have a dedicated room for your snakes which is much easier to keep at a set temperature via either home heating or by thermostat controlled space heater (a nice semi-industrial one not the house fire kind). What I've mentioned that I do personally to do this on a tank by tank level is I've essentially tightened up my gradient. My cool side is warmer, my warm side is cooler. My snakes can access anywhere between 78-83F, as a result I have to worry about humidity very little.

-We care about reptiles: Absolutely, its why people are always trying to improve their care and husbandry. Even the best of the best aren't perfect. I believe that this is an improvement on the way people have been keeping their snakes. I'm not shouting from the hilltops for everyone to change what they are doing especially when it's working for them. But I've seen the animals people who keep their snakes this way and my animals are extraordinary in my opinion. I haven't been using this method long, 2 years or so. But if I'm sitting here 5 years from now with just as perfect animals I'm at least proving that there isn't any harm done by the method.

-What is the victory in it?: I haven't had a shedding issue or any other issue since I've started adopting some of the strategies of this theory while at the same time essentially being able to ignore humidity. I know people have issues with humidity, temperature control, everything, people can do things by the book and still have issues. I'm not seeing those issues, if my snakes are shedding well, eating ferociously, and are thriving then that is my measure of success as a keeper and that is my victory. I think in general it is easier to keep a tighter gradient in the smaller confines of an enclosure if the method proves true it could solve issues for other keepers as well and that would be an even bigger victory.

Either way, you're heart is in the right place but I do encourage you go back and read through everything that was posted here. Otherwise, welcome to the forum and what kind of snakes are you keeping?
jjhill001 is offline  
Old 08-05-17, 02:54 AM   #112
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

By coincidence we were having the same debate on a Facebook group. The following is from Fran Baines.

For those that don't know of Fran she is a world leading scientist on reptile heating and lighting. Zoos around the world consult her and she has published hundreds of papers on the subject.

She is hunting out some papers from her library on the need for snakes to thermoregulate and as soon I have then I'll post a link.

If Fran says they need to thermoregulate I'll take her word over that over any number of breeders and hobbiests to be honest - she's done the research.

---
All reptiles need to thermoregulate for optimum health; they need to be able to adjust their internal body temperature according to their current physiological need. This includes an increase in body temperature when digesting food, for example. And a night drop is important (along with darkness) to regulate circadian rhythms.
Ideally, you're looking to create a thermal gradient that's above the average preferred body temperature at one end of the vivarium, as a heat source, and cooler than the preferred body temperature at the other end, as a "heat sink" (technical term for cooling-off place)...
Unfortunately if you keep the whole environment at the same temperature, the reptile can't change its body temperature at all. This is chronic stress, and can lead to poor health and poor growth.
---

This from Francis Cosqueiri - a herpetologist who's spent decades observing snakes.

---
You may not know this but Fran is a world renowned vet whose advice is sought by zoos and institutions worldwide, that has published reams of peer reviewed papers, especially on the topic she is advising on - she doesn't give "opinions" she changes the way these animals are viewed with her work. The wise would do well to sit up, shut up and pay heed when she givrs advice.

Also, yes - keeping a reptile at one temperature is absolutely terrible advice, bordering on cruelty in my opinion, regardless of the "loads of people" that say otherwise. Simply because the preferred temperature (Tp) of these animals has been shown to vary depending on age, season, gender... In fact some of my own research was on preferred temperature in reptiles and I can even name cryptic species that have been separated due to their preference for different temperatures!

Providing a thermal gradient is ALWAYS to be recommended, even for hardy Royal Pythons, because that is how these animals thermoregulate. It is essentially the basic building block of ethical reptile care.
---

As I say when Fran gives me the papers I'll post them up.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-05-17, 04:54 AM   #113
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by dannybgoode View Post
By coincidence we were having the same debate on a Facebook group. The following is from Fran Baines.

For those that don't know of Fran she is a world leading scientist on reptile heating and lighting. Zoos around the world consult her and she has published hundreds of papers on the subject.

She is hunting out some papers from her library on the need for snakes to thermoregulate and as soon I have then I'll post a link.

If Fran says they need to thermoregulate I'll take her word over that over any number of breeders and hobbiests to be honest - she's done the research.

---
All reptiles need to thermoregulate for optimum health; they need to be able to adjust their internal body temperature according to their current physiological need. This includes an increase in body temperature when digesting food, for example. And a night drop is important (along with darkness) to regulate circadian rhythms.
Ideally, you're looking to create a thermal gradient that's above the average preferred body temperature at one end of the vivarium, as a heat source, and cooler than the preferred body temperature at the other end, as a "heat sink" (technical term for cooling-off place)...
Unfortunately if you keep the whole environment at the same temperature, the reptile can't change its body temperature at all. This is chronic stress, and can lead to poor health and poor growth.
---

This from Francis Cosqueiri - a herpetologist who's spent decades observing snakes.

---
You may not know this but Fran is a world renowned vet whose advice is sought by zoos and institutions worldwide, that has published reams of peer reviewed papers, especially on the topic she is advising on - she doesn't give "opinions" she changes the way these animals are viewed with her work. The wise would do well to sit up, shut up and pay heed when she givrs advice.

Also, yes - keeping a reptile at one temperature is absolutely terrible advice, bordering on cruelty in my opinion, regardless of the "loads of people" that say otherwise. Simply because the preferred temperature (Tp) of these animals has been shown to vary depending on age, season, gender... In fact some of my own research was on preferred temperature in reptiles and I can even name cryptic species that have been separated due to their preference for different temperatures!

Providing a thermal gradient is ALWAYS to be recommended, even for hardy Royal Pythons, because that is how these animals thermoregulate. It is essentially the basic building block of ethical reptile care.
---

As I say when Fran gives me the papers I'll post them up.
My source is the curator of the Reptile Gardens and has just as much experience. I have to say once again that there is more than one way to skin a cat.
jjhill001 is offline  
Old 08-05-17, 05:09 AM   #114
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by jjhill001 View Post
My source is the curator of the Reptile Gardens and has just as much experience. I have to say once again that there is more than one way to skin a cat.
Have they had peer reviewed papers published on the subject?

If the science shows they need to thermoregulate that is it as far as I'm concerned regardless of anecdotes.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-06-17, 10:06 AM   #115
RAD House
Member
 
RAD House's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec-2014
Location: Denver
Posts: 839
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Danny, from both those quotes it sounds as if they are sharing opinions. Neither reference any work that shows their opinion holds validity. I will concede their opinion comes from a ton of experience, but that doesn't mean they have any experience keeping snakes at a stable temperature.
__________________
R.A.D. house
RAD House is offline  
Login to remove ads
Old 08-06-17, 10:40 AM   #116
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by MesoCorney View Post
Danny, from both those quotes it sounds as if they are sharing opinions. Neither reference any work that shows their opinion holds validity. I will concede their opinion comes from a ton of experience, but that doesn't mean they have any experience keeping snakes at a stable temperature.
Fran has spent decades researching reptile heating and lighting - much of it in lab conditions. She is a world renowned reptile vet who consults with the world's top zoos. She has published hundreds of scientific peer reviewed papers. I would say hers, whilst possibly just 'opinion', is far more informed than any of ours. And note as a scientist - if the evidence suggested that a single stable temperature as optimum that is what she would promote.

Francis' research is interesting as he has had to separate snakes of the same species as they had different temperature preferences the suggesting that if we find a single temperature on every multiple snakes of the same species, never mind separate species, some of these snakes may be at a sub optimal temperature.

I think aside from whether a single temperature of thermoregulation is any better than one another the fact is we simply do not know what (if there even is one) this magic temperature is for an individual snake - nevermind multiple snakes.

In humans if the core temperature deviates by more than a couple of c either way the body shuts down. So a degree of two difference in a snake temperature may be biologically very significant. How do we know therefore that it should be 26, 27, 28c - whatever. We simply don't. By keeping snakes at a single temperature you are picking an arbitrary temperature and knowing that on your snakes giving them no choice in the matter. How can this be justifiable?

Further how do we know that even if through thermoregulation a snake only changes its internal temperature by 0.5c each way this isn't significant? Again to remove this choice - to me at least - seems unnecessary. In in lieu of knowing for certain - given its a relatively trivial thing to do why not provide a basking spot and the chance to thermoregulate.

I have been given 6 or so papers on the subject of thermoregulation in snakes which I am currently saying through and then I'll post them up - hopefully with a coherent brief summary of each one.

I would of the challenge out there to find papers in support of single temperature keeping.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus

Last edited by dannybgoode; 08-06-17 at 10:55 AM..
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-06-17, 11:21 AM   #117
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

And as well as papers my other request is to tell me at what single temperature ensures should be kept and on what days and other research this figure is based on.
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-06-17, 11:54 PM   #118
jjhill001
Member
 
Join Date: Jan-2015
Location: Youngstown
Posts: 905
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

For being the world leading scientist on reptiles I can't find a single result on google, typing her name in. You don't need someone to publish it in a journal to see results.

I would challenge that she probably never kept a snake at a single temperature in order to see if there is any measurable difference. I also maintain that the majority of studies are done with the goal of understanding wild aninals more meaning that they obviously would try and replicate those conditions.
jjhill001 is offline  
Old 08-07-17, 12:50 AM   #119
dannybgoode
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2015
Posts: 2,203
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

So essentially you're advising people it's fine to deny a snake the ability to perform one of its fundamental behaviours with no scientific understanding of the importance of that behaviour and with no research or data to back up or prove what this magic temperature is or even be able tell me what it is?

You have no proof either that different species are all ok at the same temperature (and I can categorically say this is not the case).

But hey some snakes haven't died yet and some have even bred so it must be ok. The default position of people who follow breeder methodology (and I am not making just on here but in the hobby in general) is to demand papers from those advocating an alternate position.

As I say I have 6 or so papers on the subject, one of which does indeed compare snakes being allowed thermoregulate against those kept at a single temperature.

I am simply asking for the same. What scientific proof do you have that your method is not harmful - what proof do you have that denying a fundamental behaviour is ok?
__________________
0.1 B imperator, 1.0 M spilota harrisoni, 1.0 C hortulanus, 2.1 P reticulatus (Madu locality), 1.1 S amethystine, 1.1 L olivaceous, 1.0 C angulifer, 1.0 Z persicus, 0.1 P regius, 0.1 N natrix, 0.1 E climacophora, 1.0 P obsoletus, 0.1 L geluta nigrtia, 1.0 P catenifer sayi, 1.0 T lepidus
dannybgoode is offline  
Old 08-07-17, 02:14 AM   #120
TRD
Member
 
Join Date: Dec-2016
Posts: 715
Country:
Re: Keeping snakes without a hotspot

Quote:
Originally Posted by jjhill001 View Post
For being the world leading scientist on reptiles I can't find a single result on google, typing her name in. You don't need someone to publish it in a journal to see results.
Type the right name: Frances M Baines

And it's not on reptiles, it on lighting requirements for reptiles.
TRD is offline  
Login to remove ads
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:54 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2002-2026, Hobby Solutions.

right